[Music]
[Music]
power<00:00:18.000> that<00:00:18.160> is<00:00:18.279> the<00:00:18.400> word<00:00:18.600> that<00:00:18.720> comes<00:00:18.920> to
power that is the word that comes to
power that is the word that comes to
mind<00:00:20.199> we're<00:00:20.439> the<00:00:20.600> new<00:00:20.880> technologists<00:00:21.800> we<00:00:21.920> have
mind we're the new technologists we have
mind we're the new technologists we have
a<00:00:22.160> lot<00:00:22.320> of<00:00:22.519> data<00:00:22.960> so<00:00:23.199> we<00:00:23.359> have<00:00:23.599> a<00:00:23.800> lot<00:00:24.039> of<00:00:24.279> power
a lot of data so we have a lot of power
a lot of data so we have a lot of power
how<00:00:25.279> much<00:00:25.480> power<00:00:25.680> do<00:00:25.800> we<00:00:25.960> have<00:00:26.920> seen<00:00:27.320> from<00:00:27.480> a
how much power do we have seen from a
how much power do we have seen from a
movie<00:00:28.039> Apocalypse<00:00:28.519> Now<00:00:28.880> great<00:00:29.080> movie<00:00:29.960> we<00:00:30.080> got
movie Apocalypse Now great movie we got
movie Apocalypse Now great movie we got
to<00:00:30.240> get<00:00:30.359> our<00:00:30.519> hero<00:00:30.920> Captain<00:00:31.199> Willard<00:00:31.759> to<00:00:31.960> the
to get our hero Captain Willard to the
to get our hero Captain Willard to the
mouth<00:00:32.320> of<00:00:32.399> the<00:00:32.480> Nung<00:00:32.719> River<00:00:32.960> so<00:00:33.079> we<00:00:33.200> can<00:00:33.360> go
mouth of the Nung River so we can go
mouth of the Nung River so we can go
pursue<00:00:33.920> Colonel<00:00:34.239> CTS<00:00:34.719> the<00:00:34.800> way<00:00:34.920> we're<00:00:35.000> going
pursue Colonel CTS the way we're going
pursue Colonel CTS the way we're going
to<00:00:35.160> do<00:00:35.280> this<00:00:35.399> is<00:00:35.559> fly<00:00:35.879> him<00:00:36.040> in<00:00:36.320> drop<00:00:36.600> him<00:00:36.760> off<00:00:37.079> so
to do this is fly him in drop him off so
to do this is fly him in drop him off so
the<00:00:37.480> scene<00:00:38.360> the<00:00:38.600> sky<00:00:38.920> is<00:00:39.120> filled<00:00:39.440> with<00:00:39.600> this
the scene the sky is filled with this
the scene the sky is filled with this
Fleet<00:00:40.079> of<00:00:40.239> helicopters<00:00:40.840> carrying<00:00:41.120> him<00:00:41.239> in<00:00:41.559> and
Fleet of helicopters carrying him in and
Fleet of helicopters carrying him in and
there's<00:00:41.840> this<00:00:42.039> loud<00:00:42.520> thrilling<00:00:43.000> music<00:00:43.280> in<00:00:43.399> the
there's this loud thrilling music in the
there's this loud thrilling music in the
background<00:00:43.879> this<00:00:44.079> wild
[Music]
music<00:00:52.600> that's<00:00:53.039> a<00:00:53.199> lot<00:00:53.359> of<00:00:53.559> power<00:00:54.480> that's<00:00:54.640> the
music that's a lot of power that's the
music that's a lot of power that's the
kind<00:00:54.879> of<00:00:55.039> power<00:00:55.320> I<00:00:55.440> feel<00:00:55.719> in<00:00:55.879> this<00:00:56.079> room<00:00:56.600> that's
kind of power I feel in this room that's
kind of power I feel in this room that's
the<00:00:56.879> kind<00:00:57.000> of<00:00:57.199> power<00:00:57.480> we<00:00:57.719> have<00:00:58.160> because<00:00:58.480> all<00:00:58.640> of
the kind of power we have because all of
the kind of power we have because all of
the<00:00:58.879> data<00:00:59.199> that<00:00:59.320> we<00:00:59.519> have
the data that we have
the data that we have
let's<00:01:01.199> take<00:01:01.320> an
let's take an
let's take an
example<00:01:03.120> what<00:01:03.239> can<00:01:03.359> we<00:01:03.559> do<00:01:04.119> with<00:01:04.360> just<00:01:04.799> one
example what can we do with just one
example what can we do with just one
person's
person's
person's
data<00:01:07.600> what<00:01:07.720> can<00:01:07.880> we<00:01:08.000> do
data what can we do
data what can we do
with<00:01:09.880> that<00:01:10.080> guy's
with that guy's
with that guy's
data<00:01:12.759> I<00:01:12.840> can<00:01:13.000> look<00:01:13.119> at<00:01:13.200> your<00:01:13.360> financial
data I can look at your financial
data I can look at your financial
records<00:01:14.320> I<00:01:14.400> can<00:01:14.520> tell<00:01:14.680> if<00:01:14.759> you<00:01:14.880> pay<00:01:15.000> your<00:01:15.119> bills
records I can tell if you pay your bills
records I can tell if you pay your bills
on<00:01:15.520> time<00:01:15.880> I<00:01:16.000> know<00:01:16.119> if<00:01:16.200> you're<00:01:16.320> good<00:01:16.439> to<00:01:16.560> give<00:01:16.680> a
on time I know if you're good to give a
on time I know if you're good to give a
loan<00:01:17.000> to<00:01:17.840> can<00:01:18.000> look<00:01:18.119> at<00:01:18.200> your<00:01:18.280> medical<00:01:18.600> records
loan to can look at your medical records
loan to can look at your medical records
I<00:01:19.000> can<00:01:19.119> see<00:01:19.240> if<00:01:19.320> the<00:01:19.439> pump<00:01:19.640> is<00:01:19.759> still<00:01:19.960> pumping
I can see if the pump is still pumping
I can see if the pump is still pumping
see<00:01:20.720> if<00:01:20.799> you're<00:01:20.960> good<00:01:21.079> to<00:01:21.200> offer<00:01:21.479> Insurance
see if you're good to offer Insurance
see if you're good to offer Insurance
to<00:01:24.280> I<00:01:24.360> can<00:01:24.520> look<00:01:24.640> at<00:01:24.720> your<00:01:24.880> clicking<00:01:25.240> patterns
to I can look at your clicking patterns
to I can look at your clicking patterns
when<00:01:25.880> you<00:01:26.000> come<00:01:26.159> to<00:01:26.360> my<00:01:26.560> website<00:01:27.560> I<00:01:27.680> actually
when you come to my website I actually
when you come to my website I actually
know<00:01:28.000> what<00:01:28.079> you're<00:01:28.200> going<00:01:28.280> to<00:01:28.360> do<00:01:28.520> already
know what you're going to do already
know what you're going to do already
because<00:01:29.079> I've<00:01:29.240> seen<00:01:29.400> you<00:01:29.520> visit<00:01:30.040> millions<00:01:30.400> of
because I've seen you visit millions of
because I've seen you visit millions of
websites<00:01:31.159> before<00:01:31.479> and<00:01:31.600> I'm<00:01:31.680> sorry<00:01:31.920> to<00:01:32.000> tell
websites before and I'm sorry to tell
websites before and I'm sorry to tell
you<00:01:32.439> you're<00:01:32.640> like<00:01:32.759> a<00:01:32.880> poker<00:01:33.159> player<00:01:33.479> you<00:01:33.560> have
you you're like a poker player you have
you you're like a poker player you have
a<00:01:33.840> tell<00:01:34.439> I<00:01:34.520> can<00:01:34.680> tell<00:01:34.880> with<00:01:35.040> data<00:01:35.240> analysis
a tell I can tell with data analysis
a tell I can tell with data analysis
what<00:01:35.720> you're<00:01:35.799> going<00:01:35.880> to<00:01:36.000> do<00:01:36.399> before<00:01:36.759> you<00:01:37.040> even
what you're going to do before you even
what you're going to do before you even
do<00:01:37.759> it<00:01:38.759> I<00:01:38.880> know<00:01:39.040> what<00:01:39.200> you<00:01:39.439> like<00:01:40.040> I<00:01:40.159> know<00:01:40.360> who
do it I know what you like I know who
do it I know what you like I know who
you<00:01:40.680> are<00:01:41.640> and<00:01:41.799> that's<00:01:41.960> even<00:01:42.200> before<00:01:42.520> I<00:01:42.640> look<00:01:42.759> at
you are and that's even before I look at
you are and that's even before I look at
your<00:01:43.159> mail<00:01:44.159> or<00:01:44.360> your
your mail or your
your mail or your
phone<00:01:46.159> those<00:01:46.320> are<00:01:46.479> the<00:01:46.640> kind<00:01:46.759> of<00:01:46.920> things<00:01:47.200> we
phone those are the kind of things we
phone those are the kind of things we
can<00:01:47.520> do<00:01:48.040> with<00:01:48.159> the<00:01:48.360> data<00:01:48.799> that<00:01:48.960> we
can do with the data that we
can do with the data that we
have<00:01:50.759> but<00:01:50.920> I'm<00:01:51.040> not<00:01:51.520> actually<00:01:51.799> here<00:01:51.960> to<00:01:52.119> talk
have but I'm not actually here to talk
have but I'm not actually here to talk
about<00:01:52.560> what<00:01:52.680> we<00:01:52.799> can
do<00:01:56.640> I'm<00:01:56.840> here<00:01:56.960> to<00:01:57.119> talk<00:01:57.320> about<00:01:57.560> what<00:01:57.719> we<00:01:57.840> should
do I'm here to talk about what we should
do I'm here to talk about what we should
do
do
do
what's<00:02:01.600> the<00:02:01.759> right<00:02:01.960> thing<00:02:02.119> to
what's the right thing to
what's the right thing to
do<00:02:05.200> now<00:02:05.320> I<00:02:05.439> see<00:02:05.600> some<00:02:05.759> puzzled<00:02:06.159> looks<00:02:06.520> like<00:02:06.759> why
do now I see some puzzled looks like why
do now I see some puzzled looks like why
are<00:02:07.000> you<00:02:07.200> asking<00:02:07.479> us<00:02:07.680> what's<00:02:07.960> the<00:02:08.080> right<00:02:08.239> thing
are you asking us what's the right thing
are you asking us what's the right thing
to<00:02:08.560> do<00:02:09.560> we're<00:02:09.800> just<00:02:10.000> building<00:02:10.399> this<00:02:10.599> stuff
to do we're just building this stuff
to do we're just building this stuff
somebody<00:02:11.200> else<00:02:11.400> is<00:02:11.599> using
somebody else is using
somebody else is using
it<00:02:13.599> fair<00:02:13.879> enough<00:02:14.480> um<00:02:15.360> but<00:02:15.480> it<00:02:15.560> brings<00:02:15.920> me<00:02:16.720> back
it fair enough um but it brings me back
it fair enough um but it brings me back
think<00:02:17.920> about<00:02:18.480> World<00:02:18.800> War<00:02:19.239> II<00:02:20.239> some<00:02:20.400> of<00:02:20.519> our
think about World War II some of our
think about World War II some of our
great<00:02:20.879> technologists<00:02:21.480> then<00:02:21.599> some<00:02:21.720> of<00:02:21.800> our
great technologists then some of our
great technologists then some of our
great<00:02:22.360> physicists<00:02:23.720> studying<00:02:24.720> nuclear<00:02:25.160> fision
great physicists studying nuclear fision
great physicists studying nuclear fision
fusion<00:02:26.040> just<00:02:26.239> nuclear<00:02:26.840> stuff<00:02:27.440> we<00:02:27.640> gathered
fusion just nuclear stuff we gathered
fusion just nuclear stuff we gathered
together<00:02:28.760> these<00:02:28.959> physicists<00:02:29.360> in<00:02:29.480> Los
together these physicists in Los
together these physicists in Los
Alamos<00:02:31.640> see<00:02:31.879> what<00:02:32.000> they'll
Alamos see what they'll
Alamos see what they'll
build<00:02:34.200> we<00:02:34.360> want<00:02:35.040> the<00:02:35.160> people<00:02:35.440> building<00:02:35.840> the
build we want the people building the
build we want the people building the
technology<00:02:36.760> thinking<00:02:37.120> about<00:02:37.599> what<00:02:37.800> we<00:02:37.879> should
technology thinking about what we should
technology thinking about what we should
be<00:02:38.239> doing<00:02:38.640> with<00:02:38.760> the
be doing with the
be doing with the
technology<00:02:41.760> so<00:02:41.879> what<00:02:42.000> should<00:02:42.159> we<00:02:42.480> be<00:02:42.599> doing
technology so what should we be doing
technology so what should we be doing
with<00:02:42.959> that<00:02:43.120> guy's<00:02:43.840> data<00:02:44.840> should<00:02:45.040> we<00:02:45.159> be
with that guy's data should we be
with that guy's data should we be
collecting<00:02:46.000> it<00:02:47.000> Gathering<00:02:47.400> it<00:02:47.840> so<00:02:48.000> we<00:02:48.120> can
collecting it Gathering it so we can
collecting it Gathering it so we can
make<00:02:48.360> his<00:02:48.519> online<00:02:48.959> experience<00:02:49.480> better<00:02:50.280> so<00:02:50.480> we
make his online experience better so we
make his online experience better so we
can<00:02:50.720> make<00:02:51.280> money<00:02:52.280> so<00:02:52.440> we<00:02:52.560> can<00:02:52.760> protect
can make money so we can protect
can make money so we can protect
ourselves<00:02:53.440> if<00:02:53.599> we<00:02:53.959> up<00:02:54.080> to<00:02:54.239> no
ourselves if we up to no
ourselves if we up to no
good<00:02:56.400> or<00:02:57.400> should<00:02:57.640> we<00:02:57.840> respect<00:02:58.200> his<00:02:58.440> privacy
good or should we respect his privacy
good or should we respect his privacy
protect<00:02:59.319> his<00:02:59.440> dignity<00:03:00.080> and<00:03:00.280> leave<00:03:00.519> him
protect his dignity and leave him
protect his dignity and leave him
alone<00:03:02.720> which<00:03:02.840> one<00:03:03.040> is
alone which one is
alone which one is
it<00:03:05.640> how<00:03:05.760> should<00:03:05.920> we<00:03:06.040> figure<00:03:06.239> it
it how should we figure it
it how should we figure it
out<00:03:08.040> I<00:03:08.159> know<00:03:08.879> crowdsource<00:03:09.480> let's<00:03:09.640> crowdsource
out I know crowdsource let's crowdsource
out I know crowdsource let's crowdsource
this<00:03:10.959> um<00:03:11.760> so<00:03:11.920> to<00:03:12.080> get<00:03:12.200> people<00:03:12.360> warmed<00:03:12.680> up<00:03:13.319> let's
this um so to get people warmed up let's
this um so to get people warmed up let's
start<00:03:13.879> with<00:03:14.360> uh<00:03:14.840> let<00:03:15.000> start<00:03:15.239> an<00:03:15.319> easy<00:03:15.560> question
start with uh let start an easy question
start with uh let start an easy question
something<00:03:16.920> I'm<00:03:17.080> sure<00:03:17.680> everybody<00:03:18.080> here<00:03:18.239> has<00:03:18.360> an
something I'm sure everybody here has an
something I'm sure everybody here has an
opinion<00:03:18.959> about<00:03:19.959> iPhone<00:03:20.360> versus<00:03:20.720> Android
opinion about iPhone versus Android
opinion about iPhone versus Android
let's<00:03:21.239> do<00:03:21.360> this<00:03:21.480> show<00:03:21.640> a<00:03:21.799> hands
iPhone<00:03:25.799> uhhuh
iPhone uhhuh
iPhone uhhuh
Android
Android
Android
you<00:03:30.439> you'd<00:03:30.640> think<00:03:30.760> with<00:03:30.879> a<00:03:30.959> bunch<00:03:31.120> of<00:03:31.239> smart
you you'd think with a bunch of smart
you you'd think with a bunch of smart
people<00:03:31.760> we<00:03:31.840> wouldn't<00:03:32.080> be<00:03:32.200> such<00:03:32.360> suckers<00:03:32.879> just
people we wouldn't be such suckers just
people we wouldn't be such suckers just
for<00:03:33.159> the<00:03:33.280> pretty
for the pretty
for the pretty
phones<00:03:36.120> okay<00:03:36.519> next<00:03:36.799> question<00:03:37.280> a<00:03:37.439> little<00:03:37.799> bit
phones okay next question a little bit
phones okay next question a little bit
harder<00:03:39.319> should<00:03:39.599> we<00:03:39.799> be<00:03:40.159> collecting<00:03:40.640> all<00:03:40.760> of
harder should we be collecting all of
harder should we be collecting all of
that<00:03:41.280> guy's<00:03:41.640> data<00:03:42.640> to<00:03:42.799> make<00:03:42.959> his<00:03:43.159> experiences
that guy's data to make his experiences
that guy's data to make his experiences
better<00:03:44.159> and<00:03:44.280> to<00:03:44.400> protect<00:03:44.640> ourselves<00:03:44.959> in<00:03:45.040> case
better and to protect ourselves in case
better and to protect ourselves in case
it's<00:03:45.280> up<00:03:45.360> to<00:03:45.480> no<00:03:45.599> good<00:03:46.319> or<00:03:46.720> should<00:03:46.879> we<00:03:47.000> leave
it's up to no good or should we leave
it's up to no good or should we leave
him
him
him
alone<00:03:48.920> collect<00:03:49.239> his
data<00:03:54.040> leave<00:03:54.200> him
data leave him
data leave him
alone<00:03:57.360> you're<00:03:57.640> safe<00:03:58.200> it's<00:03:58.680> fine
alone you're safe it's fine
alone you're safe it's fine
okay<00:04:01.360> last<00:04:01.959> question<00:04:02.959> harder
okay last question harder
okay last question harder
question<00:04:05.239> when<00:04:05.439> trying<00:04:05.720> to
question when trying to
question when trying to
evaluate<00:04:07.519> what<00:04:07.799> we<00:04:07.920> should<00:04:08.200> do<00:04:09.120> in<00:04:09.280> this<00:04:09.560> case
evaluate what we should do in this case
evaluate what we should do in this case
should<00:04:10.560> we<00:04:10.879> use<00:04:11.879> a<00:04:12.120> conent<00:04:12.799> deontological
should we use a conent deontological
should we use a conent deontological
moral<00:04:14.040> framework<00:04:14.560> or<00:04:14.680> should<00:04:14.879> we<00:04:15.040> use<00:04:15.200> a<00:04:15.360> milit
moral framework or should we use a milit
moral framework or should we use a milit
a<00:04:16.160> million<00:04:16.680> consequentialist
a million consequentialist
a million consequentialist
one
k
Mill<00:04:26.520> not<00:04:26.800> not<00:04:26.960> as<00:04:27.080> many
Mill not not as many
Mill not not as many
votes
votes
votes
yeah<00:04:32.039> that's<00:04:32.199> a<00:04:32.360> terrifying
yeah that's a terrifying
yeah that's a terrifying
result<00:04:35.199> and<00:04:35.320> it's<00:04:35.960> terrifying<00:04:36.960> because<00:04:37.320> we
result and it's terrifying because we
result and it's terrifying because we
have<00:04:37.840> stronger<00:04:38.120> opinions<00:04:38.880> about<00:04:39.039> our
have stronger opinions about our
have stronger opinions about our
handheld<00:04:39.880> devices<00:04:40.880> than<00:04:41.039> about<00:04:41.240> the<00:04:41.360> moral
handheld devices than about the moral
handheld devices than about the moral
framework<00:04:42.120> we<00:04:42.199> should<00:04:42.400> use<00:04:42.680> to<00:04:42.880> guide<00:04:43.039> our
framework we should use to guide our
framework we should use to guide our
decisions<00:04:45.199> how<00:04:45.320> do<00:04:45.479> we<00:04:45.680> know<00:04:45.880> what<00:04:45.960> to<00:04:46.120> do<00:04:46.320> with
decisions how do we know what to do with
decisions how do we know what to do with
all<00:04:46.560> the<00:04:46.759> power<00:04:47.080> we<00:04:47.320> have<00:04:47.720> if<00:04:47.840> we<00:04:47.960> don't<00:04:48.120> have<00:04:48.240> a
all the power we have if we don't have a
all the power we have if we don't have a
moral
moral
moral
framework<00:04:50.759> we<00:04:50.880> know<00:04:51.080> more<00:04:51.280> about<00:04:51.639> mobile
framework we know more about mobile
framework we know more about mobile
operating<00:04:52.680> systems<00:04:53.400> but<00:04:53.600> what<00:04:53.759> we<00:04:53.919> really
operating systems but what we really
operating systems but what we really
need<00:04:54.680> is<00:04:54.800> a<00:04:55.000> moral<00:04:55.560> operating
need is a moral operating
need is a moral operating
system<00:04:58.840> what's<00:04:59.000> a<00:04:59.080> moral<00:04:59.280> Opera<00:04:59.560> writing
system what's a moral Opera writing
system what's a moral Opera writing
system<00:05:00.320> all<00:05:00.440> right<00:05:00.560> well<00:05:00.680> we<00:05:00.800> all<00:05:00.919> know<00:05:01.120> right
system all right well we all know right
system all right well we all know right
and<00:05:01.520> wrong<00:05:02.039> right<00:05:02.479> you<00:05:02.600> feel<00:05:02.919> good<00:05:03.080> when<00:05:03.199> you
and wrong right you feel good when you
and wrong right you feel good when you
do<00:05:03.479> something<00:05:03.800> right<00:05:04.120> you<00:05:04.280> feel<00:05:04.560> bad<00:05:04.759> when<00:05:04.880> you
do something right you feel bad when you
do something right you feel bad when you
do<00:05:05.120> something<00:05:05.440> wrong<00:05:06.000> our<00:05:06.120> parents<00:05:06.440> teach<00:05:06.600> us
do something wrong our parents teach us
do something wrong our parents teach us
that<00:05:07.160> you<00:05:07.280> know<00:05:07.639> praise<00:05:08.000> with<00:05:08.120> the<00:05:08.280> good<00:05:08.639> scold
that you know praise with the good scold
that you know praise with the good scold
with<00:05:09.160> the<00:05:09.320> bad<00:05:09.800> um<00:05:10.440> but<00:05:10.600> how<00:05:10.720> do<00:05:10.880> we<00:05:11.080> figure<00:05:11.360> out
with the bad um but how do we figure out
with the bad um but how do we figure out
what's<00:05:11.840> right<00:05:12.000> and<00:05:12.160> wrong<00:05:12.960> and<00:05:13.120> from<00:05:13.280> day<00:05:13.440> to
what's right and wrong and from day to
what's right and wrong and from day to
day<00:05:14.039> we<00:05:14.160> have<00:05:14.400> the<00:05:14.520> techniques<00:05:14.919> that<00:05:15.039> we<00:05:15.160> use
day we have the techniques that we use
day we have the techniques that we use
right<00:05:16.280> maybe<00:05:16.840> we<00:05:17.000> just<00:05:17.120> follow<00:05:17.440> our
right maybe we just follow our
right maybe we just follow our
gut<00:05:19.240> maybe<00:05:19.400> we<00:05:19.520> take<00:05:19.639> a<00:05:19.759> vote<00:05:19.960> we
gut maybe we take a vote we
gut maybe we take a vote we
crowdsource<00:05:22.240> maybe<00:05:22.440> we<00:05:22.600> punt<00:05:23.520> ask<00:05:23.720> the<00:05:23.800> legal
crowdsource maybe we punt ask the legal
crowdsource maybe we punt ask the legal
department<00:05:24.600> see<00:05:24.759> what<00:05:24.919> they
department see what they
department see what they
say<00:05:27.039> in<00:05:27.160> other<00:05:27.319> words<00:05:27.639> it's<00:05:27.880> kind<00:05:28.080> of<00:05:28.479> random
say in other words it's kind of random
say in other words it's kind of random
kind<00:05:29.680> of<00:05:29.840> ad<00:05:30.120> hoc<00:05:30.400> how<00:05:30.560> we<00:05:30.680> figure<00:05:30.919> out<00:05:31.400> what<00:05:31.560> we
kind of ad hoc how we figure out what we
kind of ad hoc how we figure out what we
should<00:05:31.919> do<00:05:32.680> um<00:05:33.440> and<00:05:33.680> maybe<00:05:34.479> if<00:05:34.560> we<00:05:34.680> want<00:05:34.800> to<00:05:34.880> be
should do um and maybe if we want to be
should do um and maybe if we want to be
on<00:05:35.160> Sher<00:05:35.680> footing<00:05:36.319> what<00:05:36.479> we<00:05:36.639> really<00:05:36.960> want<00:05:37.600> is<00:05:37.720> a
on Sher footing what we really want is a
on Sher footing what we really want is a
moral<00:05:38.080> framework<00:05:38.560> that<00:05:38.680> will<00:05:38.840> help<00:05:39.080> guide<00:05:39.280> us
moral framework that will help guide us
moral framework that will help guide us
there<00:05:39.840> that<00:05:39.919> will<00:05:40.080> tell<00:05:40.280> us<00:05:40.639> what<00:05:40.800> kinds<00:05:41.039> of
there that will tell us what kinds of
there that will tell us what kinds of
things<00:05:41.360> are<00:05:41.600> right<00:05:41.759> and<00:05:41.919> wrong<00:05:42.160> in<00:05:42.280> the<00:05:42.400> first
things are right and wrong in the first
things are right and wrong in the first
place<00:05:43.120> and<00:05:43.319> how<00:05:43.440> would<00:05:43.639> we<00:05:43.800> know<00:05:44.199> in<00:05:44.319> a<00:05:44.479> given
place and how would we know in a given
place and how would we know in a given
situation<00:05:45.560> what<00:05:45.720> to
situation what to
situation what to
do<00:05:47.560> so<00:05:47.720> let's<00:05:47.919> get<00:05:48.000> a<00:05:48.160> moral<00:05:48.440> framework<00:05:49.440> we're
do so let's get a moral framework we're
do so let's get a moral framework we're
numbers<00:05:50.080> people<00:05:50.639> living<00:05:51.080> by<00:05:51.280> numbers<00:05:52.120> how<00:05:52.280> can
numbers people living by numbers how can
numbers people living by numbers how can
we<00:05:52.560> use<00:05:52.880> numbers<00:05:53.600> as<00:05:53.759> the<00:05:53.919> basis<00:05:54.479> for<00:05:54.639> a<00:05:54.759> moral
we use numbers as the basis for a moral
we use numbers as the basis for a moral
framework<00:05:56.440> I<00:05:56.560> know<00:05:56.759> a<00:05:57.039> guy<00:05:57.440> who<00:05:57.639> did<00:05:58.199> exactly
framework I know a guy who did exactly
framework I know a guy who did exactly
that
that
that
brilliant
brilliant
brilliant
guy<00:06:02.919> he's<00:06:03.080> been<00:06:03.280> Dead<00:06:03.840> 2<00:06:04.319> 200
guy he's been Dead 2 200
guy he's been Dead 2 200
years<00:06:06.479> Plato<00:06:06.960> that's<00:06:07.160> right<00:06:07.599> remember<00:06:07.880> him
years Plato that's right remember him
years Plato that's right remember him
old<00:06:08.639> philosopher<00:06:09.639> uh<00:06:09.759> you<00:06:09.840> were<00:06:10.000> sleeping
old philosopher uh you were sleeping
old philosopher uh you were sleeping
during<00:06:10.639> that<00:06:11.039> class<00:06:12.039> um<00:06:12.720> well<00:06:12.880> Plato<00:06:13.280> he<00:06:13.360> had<00:06:13.479> a
during that class um well Plato he had a
during that class um well Plato he had a
lot<00:06:13.639> of<00:06:13.759> the<00:06:13.840> same<00:06:14.000> concerns<00:06:14.440> that<00:06:14.560> we<00:06:14.720> did<00:06:15.000> he
lot of the same concerns that we did he
lot of the same concerns that we did he
was<00:06:15.280> worried<00:06:15.599> about<00:06:15.800> right<00:06:15.960> and<00:06:16.160> wrong<00:06:16.599> he
was worried about right and wrong he
was worried about right and wrong he
wanted<00:06:16.960> to<00:06:17.080> know<00:06:17.560> what<00:06:17.720> is<00:06:17.960> just<00:06:18.479> but<00:06:18.599> he<00:06:18.800> was
wanted to know what is just but he was
wanted to know what is just but he was
worried<00:06:19.800> that<00:06:19.960> all<00:06:20.080> that<00:06:20.199> we<00:06:20.319> seem<00:06:20.520> to<00:06:20.639> be
worried that all that we seem to be
worried that all that we seem to be
doing<00:06:21.120> is<00:06:21.280> trading<00:06:21.759> opinions<00:06:22.280> about<00:06:22.560> this<00:06:23.160> he
doing is trading opinions about this he
doing is trading opinions about this he
says<00:06:23.599> something's<00:06:24.039> just<00:06:24.599> she<00:06:24.759> says<00:06:24.960> something
says something's just she says something
says something's just she says something
else<00:06:25.360> is<00:06:25.560> just<00:06:25.880> it's<00:06:26.000> kind<00:06:26.120> of<00:06:26.240> convincing
else is just it's kind of convincing
else is just it's kind of convincing
when<00:06:26.759> he<00:06:26.919> talks<00:06:27.360> when<00:06:27.479> she<00:06:27.599> talks<00:06:27.840> too<00:06:28.199> I'm
when he talks when she talks too I'm
when he talks when she talks too I'm
just<00:06:28.440> going<00:06:28.680> back<00:06:28.759> and<00:06:28.880> forth<00:06:29.080> I'm<00:06:29.160> not
just going back and forth I'm not
just going back and forth I'm not
getting<00:06:29.720> anywhere<00:06:30.280> I<00:06:30.360> don't<00:06:30.599> want<00:06:31.039> opinions<00:06:32.000> I
getting anywhere I don't want opinions I
getting anywhere I don't want opinions I
want<00:06:32.440> knowledge<00:06:33.240> I<00:06:33.319> want<00:06:33.440> to<00:06:33.560> know<00:06:33.759> the<00:06:34.000> truth
want knowledge I want to know the truth
want knowledge I want to know the truth
about<00:06:34.960> Justice<00:06:35.960> like<00:06:36.120> we<00:06:36.280> have<00:06:36.560> truths<00:06:37.080> in
about Justice like we have truths in
about Justice like we have truths in
math<00:06:38.319> in<00:06:38.560> math<00:06:39.360> we<00:06:39.520> know<00:06:40.000> the<00:06:40.160> objective<00:06:40.960> fact
math in math we know the objective fact
math in math we know the objective fact
take<00:06:42.039> a<00:06:42.160> number<00:06:42.440> any<00:06:42.639> number<00:06:43.120> two<00:06:44.000> favorite
take a number any number two favorite
take a number any number two favorite
number<00:06:44.560> I<00:06:44.680> love<00:06:44.840> that<00:06:44.960> number<00:06:45.639> um<00:06:46.479> there<00:06:46.599> are
number I love that number um there are
number I love that number um there are
truths<00:06:47.240> about<00:06:47.520> two<00:06:48.319> if<00:06:48.400> you<00:06:48.520> got<00:06:48.680> two<00:06:48.880> of
truths about two if you got two of
truths about two if you got two of
something<00:06:49.520> you<00:06:49.720> add<00:06:49.919> two<00:06:50.160> more<00:06:50.680> you<00:06:50.840> get<00:06:51.039> four
something you add two more you get four
something you add two more you get four
that's<00:06:51.759> true<00:06:52.199> no<00:06:52.360> matter<00:06:52.599> what<00:06:52.759> thing<00:06:52.880> you're
that's true no matter what thing you're
that's true no matter what thing you're
talking<00:06:53.280> about<00:06:53.560> it's<00:06:53.680> an<00:06:53.840> objective<00:06:54.319> truth
talking about it's an objective truth
talking about it's an objective truth
about<00:06:54.880> the<00:06:55.120> form<00:06:55.479> of<00:06:55.720> two<00:06:56.280> the<00:06:56.520> abstract<00:06:57.080> form
about the form of two the abstract form
about the form of two the abstract form
when<00:06:57.680> you<00:06:57.800> have<00:06:57.879> two<00:06:58.039> of<00:06:58.199> anything<00:06:58.520> two<00:06:58.720> eyes
when you have two of anything two eyes
when you have two of anything two eyes
two<00:06:59.120> ears<00:06:59.520> two<00:06:59.680> noses<00:07:00.039> just<00:07:00.360> two<00:07:00.639> protrusions
two ears two noses just two protrusions
two ears two noses just two protrusions
those<00:07:01.720> all<00:07:02.039> partake<00:07:02.720> of<00:07:02.879> the<00:07:03.080> form<00:07:03.479> of<00:07:03.720> two
those all partake of the form of two
those all partake of the form of two
they<00:07:04.840> all<00:07:05.080> participate<00:07:05.599> in<00:07:05.720> the<00:07:06.199> truths<00:07:07.199> that
they all participate in the truths that
they all participate in the truths that
two<00:07:07.759> has<00:07:08.520> they'll<00:07:08.800> have<00:07:08.960> Tess<00:07:09.440> in<00:07:09.720> them<00:07:10.720> and
two has they'll have Tess in them and
two has they'll have Tess in them and
therefore<00:07:11.280> it's<00:07:11.440> not<00:07:11.560> a<00:07:11.680> matter<00:07:11.879> of
therefore it's not a matter of
therefore it's not a matter of
opinion<00:07:14.080> what<00:07:14.280> if<00:07:14.879> Plato<00:07:15.360> thought<00:07:15.879> ethics<00:07:16.240> was
opinion what if Plato thought ethics was
opinion what if Plato thought ethics was
like<00:07:17.120> math<00:07:18.120> what<00:07:18.280> if<00:07:18.560> there<00:07:18.639> were<00:07:18.840> a<00:07:19.039> pure<00:07:19.479> form
like math what if there were a pure form
like math what if there were a pure form
of<00:07:20.160> Justice<00:07:21.039> what<00:07:21.120> if<00:07:21.240> there<00:07:21.319> are<00:07:21.520> truths
of Justice what if there are truths
of Justice what if there are truths
about<00:07:22.240> Justice<00:07:22.919> and<00:07:23.039> you<00:07:23.120> could<00:07:23.240> just<00:07:23.520> look
about Justice and you could just look
about Justice and you could just look
around<00:07:24.160> in<00:07:24.319> this<00:07:24.520> world<00:07:25.039> and<00:07:25.160> see<00:07:25.560> which
around in this world and see which
around in this world and see which
things<00:07:26.280> participated<00:07:27.000> partook<00:07:27.560> of<00:07:27.759> that<00:07:27.960> form
things participated partook of that form
things participated partook of that form
of<00:07:28.759> Justice<00:07:29.759> then<00:07:29.919> you<00:07:30.080> would<00:07:30.319> know<00:07:31.199> what<00:07:31.319> was
of Justice then you would know what was
of Justice then you would know what was
really<00:07:31.720> just<00:07:31.919> and<00:07:32.120> what<00:07:32.240> wasn't<00:07:32.680> it<00:07:32.800> wouldn't
really just and what wasn't it wouldn't
really just and what wasn't it wouldn't
be<00:07:33.160> a<00:07:33.319> matter<00:07:33.800> of<00:07:33.960> just<00:07:34.160> opinion<00:07:34.560> or<00:07:34.720> just
be a matter of just opinion or just
be a matter of just opinion or just
appearances<00:07:37.639> that's<00:07:37.800> a<00:07:38.160> stunning<00:07:38.800> Vision<00:07:39.639> I
appearances that's a stunning Vision I
appearances that's a stunning Vision I
mean<00:07:40.160> think<00:07:40.360> about<00:07:40.560> that<00:07:40.720> how<00:07:40.919> Grand<00:07:41.240> how
mean think about that how Grand how
mean think about that how Grand how
ambitious<00:07:42.000> that's<00:07:42.599> that's<00:07:43.000> like<00:07:43.160> as
ambitious that's that's like as
ambitious that's that's like as
ambitious<00:07:43.720> as<00:07:43.879> we<00:07:44.000> are<00:07:44.360> he<00:07:44.479> wants<00:07:44.680> to<00:07:44.879> solve
ambitious as we are he wants to solve
ambitious as we are he wants to solve
ethics<00:07:46.879> he<00:07:47.000> wants<00:07:47.280> objective<00:07:48.120> truths<00:07:49.120> if<00:07:49.280> you
ethics he wants objective truths if you
ethics he wants objective truths if you
if<00:07:49.960> you<00:07:50.159> think<00:07:50.440> that<00:07:50.639> way<00:07:51.240> you<00:07:51.400> have<00:07:51.560> a
if you think that way you have a
if you think that way you have a
platonist<00:07:52.560> moral
platonist moral
platonist moral
framework<00:07:54.960> if<00:07:55.039> you<00:07:55.120> don't<00:07:55.319> think<00:07:55.520> that<00:07:55.680> way
framework if you don't think that way
framework if you don't think that way
well<00:07:56.440> you<00:07:56.560> have<00:07:56.639> a<00:07:56.720> lot<00:07:56.840> of<00:07:57.000> company<00:07:57.319> in<00:07:57.400> the
well you have a lot of company in the
well you have a lot of company in the
history<00:07:57.759> of<00:07:57.879> Western<00:07:58.240> philosophy<00:07:58.759> because
history of Western philosophy because
history of Western philosophy because
that<00:07:59.319> the<00:07:59.400> Tidy<00:07:59.759> idea<00:08:00.159> you<00:08:00.280> know<00:08:00.520> people
that the Tidy idea you know people
that the Tidy idea you know people
criticized<00:08:01.319> it<00:08:01.599> Aristotle<00:08:02.240> was<00:08:02.759> in
criticized it Aristotle was in
criticized it Aristotle was in
particular<00:08:03.280> he<00:08:03.360> was<00:08:03.520> not<00:08:03.720> amused<00:08:04.440> um<00:08:05.080> he
particular he was not amused um he
particular he was not amused um he
thought<00:08:05.319> it<00:08:05.400> was<00:08:05.759> Impractical<00:08:06.759> uh<00:08:07.360> Aristotle
thought it was Impractical uh Aristotle
thought it was Impractical uh Aristotle
said<00:08:08.520> we<00:08:08.599> should<00:08:08.800> seek<00:08:09.199> only<00:08:09.599> so<00:08:09.840> much
said we should seek only so much
said we should seek only so much
Precision<00:08:10.680> in<00:08:10.840> each<00:08:11.120> subject<00:08:11.720> as<00:08:11.919> that
Precision in each subject as that
Precision in each subject as that
subject<00:08:12.560> allows<00:08:13.560> Aristotle<00:08:14.080> thought<00:08:14.280> ethics
subject allows Aristotle thought ethics
subject allows Aristotle thought ethics
wasn't<00:08:14.840> a<00:08:14.960> lot<00:08:15.159> like<00:08:15.440> math<00:08:16.440> he<00:08:16.599> thought<00:08:17.000> ethics
wasn't a lot like math he thought ethics
wasn't a lot like math he thought ethics
was<00:08:17.400> a<00:08:17.479> matter<00:08:17.680> of<00:08:17.800> making<00:08:18.039> decisions<00:08:18.400> in<00:08:18.560> the
was a matter of making decisions in the
was a matter of making decisions in the
Here<00:08:18.879> and<00:08:19.120> Now<00:08:19.800> using<00:08:20.080> our<00:08:20.280> best<00:08:20.520> judgment<00:08:21.120> to
Here and Now using our best judgment to
Here and Now using our best judgment to
find<00:08:22.159> the<00:08:22.360> right<00:08:22.639> path<00:08:23.599> if<00:08:23.720> you<00:08:23.840> think<00:08:24.000> that
find the right path if you think that
find the right path if you think that
Plato's<00:08:24.599> not<00:08:24.720> your<00:08:24.919> guy<00:08:25.560> but<00:08:25.680> don't<00:08:25.919> give<00:08:26.280> up
Plato's not your guy but don't give up
Plato's not your guy but don't give up
maybe<00:08:27.560> there's<00:08:27.879> another<00:08:28.319> way<00:08:28.919> that<00:08:29.039> we<00:08:29.319> can
maybe there's another way that we can
maybe there's another way that we can
use<00:08:30.080> numbers<00:08:30.599> as<00:08:30.759> the<00:08:30.960> basis<00:08:31.520> of<00:08:31.639> our<00:08:31.840> moral
use numbers as the basis of our moral
use numbers as the basis of our moral
framework<00:08:34.039> how<00:08:34.159> about<00:08:34.440> this<00:08:35.320> what<00:08:35.479> if<00:08:36.000> in<00:08:36.159> any
framework how about this what if in any
framework how about this what if in any
situation<00:08:37.240> you<00:08:37.320> could<00:08:37.519> just<00:08:38.000> calculate<00:08:39.000> look
situation you could just calculate look
situation you could just calculate look
at<00:08:39.279> the<00:08:39.560> choices<00:08:40.560> measure<00:08:40.959> out<00:08:41.440> which<00:08:41.560> one's
at the choices measure out which one's
at the choices measure out which one's
better<00:08:42.320> and<00:08:42.519> know<00:08:42.800> what<00:08:42.919> to<00:08:43.120> do<00:08:43.959> that<00:08:44.080> sound
better and know what to do that sound
better and know what to do that sound
familiar<00:08:45.399> y<00:08:45.800> That's<00:08:45.920> a<00:08:46.360> utilitarian<00:08:47.360> moral
familiar y That's a utilitarian moral
familiar y That's a utilitarian moral
framework<00:08:48.480> John<00:08:48.680> Stewart<00:08:49.000> Mill<00:08:49.240> who's<00:08:49.399> a
framework John Stewart Mill who's a
framework John Stewart Mill who's a
great<00:08:49.680> advocate<00:08:50.000> of<00:08:50.120> this<00:08:50.519> nice<00:08:50.720> guy<00:08:50.959> besides
great advocate of this nice guy besides
great advocate of this nice guy besides
um<00:08:52.279> and<00:08:52.680> only<00:08:52.880> been<00:08:53.040> dead<00:08:53.399> 200<00:08:53.640> years<00:08:54.040> um<00:08:54.839> so
um and only been dead 200 years um so
um and only been dead 200 years um so
basis<00:08:55.760> of<00:08:55.880> utilitarianism<00:08:56.560> I'm<00:08:56.640> sure<00:08:56.760> you're
basis of utilitarianism I'm sure you're
basis of utilitarianism I'm sure you're
familiar<00:08:57.279> at<00:08:57.399> least<00:08:57.800> the<00:08:57.959> three<00:08:58.240> people<00:08:58.560> who
familiar at least the three people who
familiar at least the three people who
voted<00:08:58.959> for<00:08:59.440> before<00:08:59.720> familiar<00:09:00.040> with<00:09:00.200> this<00:09:00.720> but
voted for before familiar with this but
voted for before familiar with this but
here's<00:09:01.760> the<00:09:01.839> way<00:09:01.959> it<00:09:02.040> works<00:09:02.440> what<00:09:02.600> if<00:09:02.839> morals
here's the way it works what if morals
here's the way it works what if morals
what<00:09:03.800> if<00:09:04.000> what<00:09:04.160> makes<00:09:04.399> something<00:09:04.760> moral<00:09:05.279> is
what if what makes something moral is
what if what makes something moral is
just<00:09:05.600> a<00:09:05.800> matter<00:09:06.240> of<00:09:06.399> if<00:09:06.519> it<00:09:06.839> maximizes
just a matter of if it maximizes
just a matter of if it maximizes
Pleasure<00:09:08.200> and<00:09:08.360> minimizes<00:09:09.000> Pain<00:09:10.000> it's<00:09:10.160> not
Pleasure and minimizes Pain it's not
Pleasure and minimizes Pain it's not
something<00:09:10.720> intrinsic<00:09:11.600> to<00:09:11.800> the<00:09:12.000> ACT<00:09:12.320> it's<00:09:12.440> not
something intrinsic to the ACT it's not
something intrinsic to the ACT it's not
like<00:09:12.640> it's<00:09:12.800> relation<00:09:13.200> to<00:09:13.320> some<00:09:13.560> abstract<00:09:14.040> form
like it's relation to some abstract form
like it's relation to some abstract form
it's<00:09:14.720> just<00:09:14.839> a<00:09:14.920> matter<00:09:15.160> of<00:09:15.320> the<00:09:15.640> consequences
it's just a matter of the consequences
it's just a matter of the consequences
you<00:09:16.800> just<00:09:16.959> look<00:09:17.079> at<00:09:17.200> the<00:09:17.399> consequences<00:09:18.120> and
you just look at the consequences and
you just look at the consequences and
see<00:09:18.440> if<00:09:18.680> overall<00:09:19.120> it's<00:09:19.279> for<00:09:19.560> the<00:09:19.720> good<00:09:19.959> or<00:09:20.079> for
see if overall it's for the good or for
see if overall it's for the good or for
the<00:09:20.440> worse<00:09:21.120> that<00:09:21.200> would<00:09:21.360> be<00:09:21.480> simple<00:09:22.000> then<00:09:22.160> we
the worse that would be simple then we
the worse that would be simple then we
know<00:09:22.519> what<00:09:22.640> to<00:09:22.839> do<00:09:23.720> let's<00:09:23.920> take<00:09:24.040> an<00:09:24.200> example
know what to do let's take an example
know what to do let's take an example
suppose<00:09:25.560> I<00:09:25.720> go<00:09:25.920> up<00:09:26.600> and<00:09:26.720> I<00:09:26.920> say<00:09:27.519> I'm<00:09:27.640> going<00:09:27.720> to
suppose I go up and I say I'm going to
suppose I go up and I say I'm going to
take<00:09:28.040> your<00:09:28.200> phone<00:09:28.600> not<00:09:28.720> just<00:09:28.920> because<00:09:29.200> it<00:09:29.320> rang
take your phone not just because it rang
take your phone not just because it rang
earlier<00:09:30.000> but<00:09:30.120> I'm<00:09:30.200> going<00:09:30.320> to<00:09:30.480> take<00:09:30.680> it<00:09:31.160> because
earlier but I'm going to take it because
earlier but I'm going to take it because
I<00:09:32.279> made<00:09:32.440> a<00:09:32.560> little<00:09:32.920> calculation<00:09:33.920> I<00:09:34.040> thought
I made a little calculation I thought
I made a little calculation I thought
that<00:09:34.519> guy<00:09:34.680> looks<00:09:35.160> suspicious<00:09:36.160> and<00:09:36.399> what<00:09:36.600> if
that guy looks suspicious and what if
that guy looks suspicious and what if
he's<00:09:37.440> been<00:09:37.560> sending<00:09:37.920> little<00:09:38.160> messages<00:09:38.640> to<00:09:38.839> Bin
he's been sending little messages to Bin
he's been sending little messages to Bin
Laden's<00:09:39.480> Hideout<00:09:39.880> or<00:09:40.000> whoever<00:09:40.320> took<00:09:40.519> over
Laden's Hideout or whoever took over
Laden's Hideout or whoever took over
after<00:09:41.040> Bin<00:09:41.200> Laden<00:09:42.079> and<00:09:42.200> he's<00:09:42.440> actually<00:09:42.760> like<00:09:43.079> a
after Bin Laden and he's actually like a
after Bin Laden and he's actually like a
terrorist<00:09:43.760> like<00:09:43.839> a<00:09:43.920> Sleeper<00:09:44.320> Cell<00:09:44.760> I'm<00:09:44.839> gonna
terrorist like a Sleeper Cell I'm gonna
terrorist like a Sleeper Cell I'm gonna
find<00:09:45.440> that<00:09:45.560> out<00:09:45.880> and<00:09:46.000> when<00:09:46.120> I<00:09:46.360> find<00:09:46.760> that<00:09:46.920> out
find that out and when I find that out
find that out and when I find that out
I'm<00:09:47.440> going<00:09:47.560> to<00:09:47.720> prevent<00:09:48.079> a<00:09:48.320> huge<00:09:48.680> amount<00:09:48.880> of
I'm going to prevent a huge amount of
I'm going to prevent a huge amount of
damage<00:09:49.640> that<00:09:49.800> he<00:09:49.959> could<00:09:50.240> cause<00:09:51.200> that<00:09:51.360> has<00:09:51.440> a
damage that he could cause that has a
damage that he could cause that has a
very<00:09:52.000> high<00:09:52.240> utility<00:09:52.680> to<00:09:52.800> prevent<00:09:53.079> that<00:09:53.320> damage
very high utility to prevent that damage
very high utility to prevent that damage
and<00:09:53.959> compared<00:09:54.320> to<00:09:54.480> the<00:09:54.640> little<00:09:54.880> pain<00:09:55.120> that
and compared to the little pain that
and compared to the little pain that
it's<00:09:55.360> going<00:09:55.440> to<00:09:55.600> cause<00:09:55.920> because<00:09:56.040> it's<00:09:56.160> going
it's going to cause because it's going
it's going to cause because it's going
to<00:09:56.320> be<00:09:56.399> embarrassing<00:09:56.880> when<00:09:57.000> I'm<00:09:57.120> looking<00:09:57.279> on
to be embarrassing when I'm looking on
to be embarrassing when I'm looking on
his<00:09:57.600> phone<00:09:57.920> and<00:09:58.200> seeing<00:09:58.440> he<00:09:58.560> has<00:09:58.640> a<00:09:58.720> farm<00:09:58.920> bu
his phone and seeing he has a farm bu
his phone and seeing he has a farm bu
problem<00:09:59.680> and<00:09:59.800> that<00:09:59.959> whole<00:10:00.360> bit<00:10:01.360> that's<00:10:01.720> over
problem and that whole bit that's over
problem and that whole bit that's over
overwhelmed<00:10:03.519> by<00:10:03.680> the<00:10:03.880> value<00:10:04.680> of<00:10:04.839> looking<00:10:05.040> at
overwhelmed by the value of looking at
overwhelmed by the value of looking at
the<00:10:05.279> phone<00:10:06.240> if<00:10:06.320> you<00:10:06.480> feel<00:10:06.760> that<00:10:06.920> way<00:10:07.279> that's<00:10:07.440> a
the phone if you feel that way that's a
the phone if you feel that way that's a
utilitarian
utilitarian
utilitarian
choice<00:10:11.440> but<00:10:11.640> maybe<00:10:11.839> you<00:10:12.000> don't<00:10:12.200> feel<00:10:12.480> that<00:10:12.640> way
choice but maybe you don't feel that way
choice but maybe you don't feel that way
either<00:10:13.680> maybe<00:10:13.880> you<00:10:14.040> think<00:10:14.760> it's<00:10:14.959> his<00:10:15.240> phone
either maybe you think it's his phone
either maybe you think it's his phone
it's<00:10:16.360> wrong<00:10:16.800> to<00:10:17.040> take<00:10:17.320> his<00:10:17.560> phone<00:10:18.360> because
it's wrong to take his phone because
it's wrong to take his phone because
he's<00:10:18.800> a<00:10:19.079> person<00:10:19.839> and<00:10:20.000> he<00:10:20.200> has<00:10:20.440> rights<00:10:20.800> and<00:10:20.920> he
he's a person and he has rights and he
he's a person and he has rights and he
has<00:10:21.320> dignity<00:10:21.959> and<00:10:22.120> we<00:10:22.240> can't<00:10:22.480> just<00:10:22.680> interfere
has dignity and we can't just interfere
has dignity and we can't just interfere
with<00:10:23.440> that<00:10:23.760> he<00:10:23.920> has<00:10:24.519> autonomy<00:10:25.519> doesn't<00:10:25.959> matter
with that he has autonomy doesn't matter
with that he has autonomy doesn't matter
what<00:10:26.519> the<00:10:26.680> calculation<00:10:27.240> are<00:10:27.640> there<00:10:27.760> are
what the calculation are there are
what the calculation are there are
things<00:10:28.160> that<00:10:28.279> are<00:10:28.480> intrinsic<00:10:29.399> Al<00:10:29.640> wrong<00:10:30.240> like
things that are intrinsic Al wrong like
things that are intrinsic Al wrong like
lying<00:10:31.079> is<00:10:31.600> wrong<00:10:32.600> like<00:10:32.760> torturing<00:10:33.240> innocent
lying is wrong like torturing innocent
lying is wrong like torturing innocent
children<00:10:34.040> is
children is
children is
wrong<00:10:35.839> Kant<00:10:36.240> was<00:10:36.480> very<00:10:36.680> good<00:10:36.839> on<00:10:37.000> this
wrong Kant was very good on this
wrong Kant was very good on this
point<00:10:38.920> and<00:10:39.040> he<00:10:39.120> said<00:10:39.320> it<00:10:39.399> a<00:10:39.519> little<00:10:39.680> better
point and he said it a little better
point and he said it a little better
than<00:10:40.040> I'll<00:10:40.320> say<00:10:40.480> it<00:10:41.279> he<00:10:41.440> said<00:10:41.880> we<00:10:41.959> should<00:10:42.160> use
than I'll say it he said we should use
than I'll say it he said we should use
our<00:10:42.600> reason<00:10:43.160> to<00:10:43.320> figure<00:10:43.560> out<00:10:43.800> the<00:10:43.959> rules<00:10:44.560> by
our reason to figure out the rules by
our reason to figure out the rules by
which<00:10:44.880> we<00:10:45.079> should<00:10:45.240> guide<00:10:45.399> our<00:10:45.560> conduct<00:10:46.000> and
which we should guide our conduct and
which we should guide our conduct and
then<00:10:46.240> it<00:10:46.360> is<00:10:46.480> our<00:10:46.920> duty<00:10:47.920> to<00:10:48.120> follow<00:10:48.440> those
then it is our duty to follow those
then it is our duty to follow those
rules<00:10:49.120> it's<00:10:49.279> not<00:10:49.399> a<00:10:49.560> matter<00:10:49.760> of
rules it's not a matter of
rules it's not a matter of
calculation<00:10:52.200> but<00:10:52.360> let's<00:10:52.560> stop<00:10:53.480> we're<00:10:53.800> right
calculation but let's stop we're right
calculation but let's stop we're right
in<00:10:54.240> the<00:10:54.440> thick<00:10:54.600> of<00:10:54.720> it<00:10:54.920> this<00:10:55.160> philosophical
in the thick of it this philosophical
in the thick of it this philosophical
Thicket<00:10:57.480> and<00:10:57.600> this<00:10:57.760> goes<00:10:57.920> on<00:10:58.160> for<00:10:58.440> thousands
Thicket and this goes on for thousands
Thicket and this goes on for thousands
of<00:10:59.200> years<00:11:00.120> because<00:11:00.360> these<00:11:00.480> are<00:11:00.680> hard
of years because these are hard
of years because these are hard
questions<00:11:01.279> and<00:11:01.440> I've<00:11:01.600> only<00:11:01.800> got<00:11:01.959> 15<00:11:02.760> minutes
questions and I've only got 15 minutes
questions and I've only got 15 minutes
so<00:11:03.920> let's<00:11:04.079> cut<00:11:04.200> to<00:11:04.360> the
so let's cut to the
so let's cut to the
chase<00:11:06.120> how<00:11:06.560> should<00:11:07.040> we<00:11:07.200> be<00:11:07.399> making<00:11:07.760> our
chase how should we be making our
chase how should we be making our
decisions<00:11:09.639> is<00:11:09.720> it<00:11:10.079> Plato<00:11:10.440> is<00:11:10.519> it<00:11:10.639> Aristotle<00:11:11.079> is
decisions is it Plato is it Aristotle is
decisions is it Plato is it Aristotle is
it<00:11:11.279> Kant<00:11:11.600> is<00:11:11.680> it<00:11:11.839> Mill<00:11:12.639> what<00:11:12.760> should<00:11:12.959> we<00:11:13.079> be
it Kant is it Mill what should we be
it Kant is it Mill what should we be
doing<00:11:14.200> what's<00:11:14.440> the<00:11:14.600> answer<00:11:15.120> what's<00:11:15.279> the
doing what's the answer what's the
doing what's the answer what's the
formula<00:11:16.040> that<00:11:16.200> we<00:11:16.399> can<00:11:16.680> use<00:11:17.279> in<00:11:17.480> any<00:11:17.720> situation
formula that we can use in any situation
formula that we can use in any situation
to<00:11:18.279> determine<00:11:18.760> what<00:11:18.880> we<00:11:19.000> should<00:11:19.279> do<00:11:19.760> whether
to determine what we should do whether
to determine what we should do whether
we<00:11:20.079> should<00:11:20.320> use<00:11:20.720> that<00:11:20.920> guy's<00:11:21.200> data<00:11:21.440> or<00:11:21.600> not
we should use that guy's data or not
we should use that guy's data or not
what's<00:11:22.240> the
formula<00:11:26.680> there's<00:11:26.880> not<00:11:27.040> a
formula there's not a
formula there's not a
formula
formula
formula
there's<00:11:29.959> not<00:11:30.079> a<00:11:30.240> simple<00:11:30.680> answer<00:11:31.680> ethics<00:11:32.120> is
there's not a simple answer ethics is
there's not a simple answer ethics is
hard<00:11:34.760> ethics<00:11:35.120> requires
hard ethics requires
hard ethics requires
thinking<00:11:38.600> and<00:11:38.760> that's
thinking and that's
thinking and that's
uncomfortable<00:11:40.720> I<00:11:41.079> know<00:11:42.079> I<00:11:42.200> spent<00:11:42.519> a<00:11:42.639> lot<00:11:42.760> of<00:11:42.959> my
uncomfortable I know I spent a lot of my
uncomfortable I know I spent a lot of my
career<00:11:43.760> in<00:11:43.959> artificial<00:11:44.440> intelligence<00:11:45.120> trying
career in artificial intelligence trying
career in artificial intelligence trying
to<00:11:45.519> build<00:11:45.839> machines<00:11:46.440> that<00:11:46.560> could<00:11:46.720> do<00:11:46.920> some<00:11:47.079> of
to build machines that could do some of
to build machines that could do some of
this<00:11:47.399> thinking<00:11:47.720> for<00:11:47.920> us<00:11:48.120> that<00:11:48.240> could<00:11:48.440> give<00:11:48.600> us
this thinking for us that could give us
this thinking for us that could give us
answers<00:11:50.000> but<00:11:50.399> but<00:11:50.600> they<00:11:50.839> can't<00:11:51.600> you<00:11:51.760> can't
answers but but they can't you can't
answers but but they can't you can't
just<00:11:52.200> take<00:11:52.480> human<00:11:52.800> thinking<00:11:53.240> and<00:11:53.440> put<00:11:53.600> it<00:11:53.760> into
just take human thinking and put it into
just take human thinking and put it into
a<00:11:54.240> machine<00:11:55.240> we're<00:11:55.560> the<00:11:55.680> ones<00:11:55.920> who<00:11:56.120> have<00:11:56.240> to<00:11:56.440> do
a machine we're the ones who have to do
a machine we're the ones who have to do
it<00:11:58.399> happily
it happily
it happily
we're<00:11:59.680> not<00:11:59.880> machines<00:12:00.839> and<00:12:01.040> we<00:12:01.200> can<00:12:01.519> do<00:12:01.720> it<00:12:02.320> not
we're not machines and we can do it not
we're not machines and we can do it not
only<00:12:02.800> can<00:12:03.000> we<00:12:03.200> think<00:12:03.920> we
only can we think we
only can we think we
must<00:12:05.760> Hana<00:12:06.079> erant
must Hana erant
must Hana erant
said<00:12:08.240> the<00:12:08.440> sad<00:12:09.200> truth<00:12:10.200> is<00:12:10.320> that<00:12:10.519> most<00:12:10.760> evil
said the sad truth is that most evil
said the sad truth is that most evil
done<00:12:11.200> in<00:12:11.320> this<00:12:11.480> world<00:12:11.959> is<00:12:12.160> not<00:12:12.399> done<00:12:12.680> by<00:12:12.839> people
done in this world is not done by people
done in this world is not done by people
who<00:12:13.360> choose<00:12:13.800> to<00:12:13.959> be
who choose to be
who choose to be
evil<00:12:15.760> it<00:12:15.920> arises<00:12:16.399> from<00:12:16.680> not
evil it arises from not
evil it arises from not
thinking<00:12:19.240> that's<00:12:19.399> what<00:12:19.519> she<00:12:19.639> called<00:12:19.880> the
thinking that's what she called the
thinking that's what she called the
banality<00:12:20.800> of
banality of
banality of
evil<00:12:23.199> and<00:12:23.320> the<00:12:23.519> response<00:12:24.000> to<00:12:24.199> that<00:12:24.560> is<00:12:24.959> that<00:12:25.079> we
evil and the response to that is that we
evil and the response to that is that we
demand<00:12:25.959> the<00:12:26.199> exercise<00:12:26.720> of<00:12:26.880> thinking<00:12:27.199> from
demand the exercise of thinking from
demand the exercise of thinking from
every<00:12:27.639> sane<00:12:28.120> person
every sane person
every sane person
so<00:12:30.480> let's<00:12:30.680> do<00:12:30.920> that<00:12:31.480> let's<00:12:31.760> think<00:12:32.199> in<00:12:32.320> fact
so let's do that let's think in fact
so let's do that let's think in fact
let's<00:12:32.800> start<00:12:33.480> right<00:12:33.760> now<00:12:34.760> every<00:12:35.000> person<00:12:35.279> in
let's start right now every person in
let's start right now every person in
this<00:12:35.560> room<00:12:36.040> do<00:12:36.480> this<00:12:37.480> think<00:12:37.800> of<00:12:37.959> the<00:12:38.160> last<00:12:38.440> time
this room do this think of the last time
this room do this think of the last time
you<00:12:39.199> had<00:12:39.440> a<00:12:39.600> decision<00:12:39.920> to<00:12:40.120> make<00:12:40.480> where<00:12:40.639> you
you had a decision to make where you
you had a decision to make where you
were<00:12:40.920> worried<00:12:41.360> to<00:12:41.519> do<00:12:41.839> the<00:12:42.040> right<00:12:42.279> thing<00:12:43.000> where
were worried to do the right thing where
were worried to do the right thing where
you<00:12:43.240> wondered<00:12:43.560> about<00:12:43.839> what<00:12:44.000> should<00:12:44.279> I<00:12:44.440> be
you wondered about what should I be
you wondered about what should I be
doing<00:12:45.480> bring<00:12:45.760> that<00:12:45.920> to<00:12:46.120> mind<00:12:46.880> and<00:12:47.240> now<00:12:48.240> reflect
doing bring that to mind and now reflect
doing bring that to mind and now reflect
on<00:12:48.839> that<00:12:49.000> and<00:12:49.160> say<00:12:49.600> how<00:12:49.800> did<00:12:49.959> I<00:12:50.120> come<00:12:50.279> up<00:12:50.440> with
on that and say how did I come up with
on that and say how did I come up with
that<00:12:50.880> decision<00:12:51.880> what<00:12:52.000> did<00:12:52.160> I<00:12:52.279> do<00:12:52.480> did<00:12:52.639> I<00:12:52.880> follow
that decision what did I do did I follow
that decision what did I do did I follow
my<00:12:53.560> gut<00:12:54.560> did<00:12:54.680> I<00:12:54.839> have<00:12:54.920> somebody<00:12:55.199> vote<00:12:55.399> on<00:12:55.519> it
my gut did I have somebody vote on it
my gut did I have somebody vote on it
did<00:12:55.760> I<00:12:55.839> punt<00:12:56.040> to<00:12:56.199> legal<00:12:57.160> or<00:12:57.360> now<00:12:57.480> we<00:12:57.600> have<00:12:57.720> a<00:12:57.839> few
did I punt to legal or now we have a few
did I punt to legal or now we have a few
more<00:12:58.199> choices
more choices
more choices
did<00:12:59.760> I<00:13:00.000> evaluate<00:13:00.959> what<00:13:01.079> would<00:13:01.240> be<00:13:01.680> the<00:13:01.839> highest
did I evaluate what would be the highest
did I evaluate what would be the highest
pleasure<00:13:02.600> like<00:13:02.880> Milwood<00:13:03.880> or<00:13:04.079> like<00:13:04.240> K<00:13:04.480> did<00:13:04.600> I
pleasure like Milwood or like K did I
pleasure like Milwood or like K did I
use<00:13:04.839> reason<00:13:05.120> to<00:13:05.199> figure<00:13:05.360> out<00:13:05.480> what<00:13:05.560> was
use reason to figure out what was
use reason to figure out what was
intrinsically<00:13:06.279> right<00:13:06.839> think<00:13:07.000> about<00:13:07.160> it
intrinsically right think about it
intrinsically right think about it
really<00:13:07.639> bring<00:13:07.839> it<00:13:07.959> to<00:13:08.079> mind<00:13:08.560> this<00:13:08.680> is
really bring it to mind this is
really bring it to mind this is
important<00:13:09.240> it<00:13:09.320> is<00:13:09.519> so<00:13:09.800> important<00:13:10.360> we<00:13:10.480> are
important it is so important we are
important it is so important we are
going<00:13:10.760> to<00:13:10.920> spend<00:13:11.360> 30<00:13:11.959> seconds<00:13:12.360> of<00:13:12.600> valuable
going to spend 30 seconds of valuable
going to spend 30 seconds of valuable
Ted<00:13:13.399> Talk<00:13:13.680> time<00:13:14.120> doing<00:13:14.399> nothing<00:13:14.680> but<00:13:14.880> thinking
Ted Talk time doing nothing but thinking
Ted Talk time doing nothing but thinking
about<00:13:15.320> this<00:13:15.560> are<00:13:15.639> you<00:13:15.880> ready
go
stop<00:13:35.480> good<00:13:36.120> work<00:13:37.120> what<00:13:37.240> you<00:13:37.399> just<00:13:37.600> did<00:13:38.480> that's
stop good work what you just did that's
stop good work what you just did that's
the<00:13:38.880> first<00:13:39.199> step<00:13:39.639> towards<00:13:40.000> taking
the first step towards taking
the first step towards taking
responsibility<00:13:41.320> for<00:13:41.519> what<00:13:41.680> we<00:13:41.800> should<00:13:42.079> do
responsibility for what we should do
responsibility for what we should do
with<00:13:42.760> all<00:13:42.880> of<00:13:43.000> our
with all of our
with all of our
power<00:13:46.199> now<00:13:46.399> the<00:13:46.560> next<00:13:46.800> step<00:13:47.440> try
power now the next step try
power now the next step try
this<00:13:49.800> go<00:13:50.000> find<00:13:50.160> a<00:13:50.279> friend<00:13:50.639> and<00:13:50.880> explain<00:13:51.399> to
this go find a friend and explain to
this go find a friend and explain to
them<00:13:52.079> how<00:13:52.240> you<00:13:52.399> made<00:13:52.600> that<00:13:53.000> decision<00:13:54.000> not
them how you made that decision not
them how you made that decision not
right<00:13:54.279> now<00:13:54.440> wait<00:13:54.560> till<00:13:54.680> I<00:13:54.800> finish<00:13:55.040> talking<00:13:55.360> do
right now wait till I finish talking do
right now wait till I finish talking do
it<00:13:55.600> over<00:13:55.800> lunch<00:13:56.880> um<00:13:57.880> and<00:13:58.000> don't<00:13:58.160> just<00:13:58.279> find
it over lunch um and don't just find
it over lunch um and don't just find
another<00:13:58.839> technologist<00:13:59.600> friend<00:14:00.600> find
another technologist friend find
another technologist friend find
somebody<00:14:01.279> different<00:14:01.959> than<00:14:02.160> you<00:14:02.600> find<00:14:02.800> an
somebody different than you find an
somebody different than you find an
artist<00:14:03.639> or<00:14:03.759> a<00:14:04.000> writer<00:14:05.000> or<00:14:05.199> heaven<00:14:05.399> forbid<00:14:05.720> find
artist or a writer or heaven forbid find
artist or a writer or heaven forbid find
a<00:14:06.000> philosopher<00:14:06.480> and<00:14:06.600> talk<00:14:06.800> to<00:14:06.959> them<00:14:07.360> in<00:14:07.519> fact
a philosopher and talk to them in fact
a philosopher and talk to them in fact
find<00:14:08.720> find<00:14:08.959> somebody<00:14:09.320> from<00:14:09.480> the<00:14:09.639> humanities
find find somebody from the humanities
find find somebody from the humanities
why<00:14:10.680> because<00:14:10.959> they<00:14:11.120> think<00:14:11.320> about<00:14:11.680> problems
why because they think about problems
why because they think about problems
differently<00:14:12.600> than<00:14:12.720> we<00:14:12.880> do<00:14:13.040> as<00:14:13.199> technologists
differently than we do as technologists
differently than we do as technologists
I<00:14:14.160> mean<00:14:14.320> just<00:14:14.519> a<00:14:14.720> few<00:14:14.959> days<00:14:15.199> ago<00:14:15.680> right<00:14:15.880> across
I mean just a few days ago right across
I mean just a few days ago right across
the<00:14:16.240> street<00:14:16.519> from<00:14:16.680> here<00:14:16.959> there's<00:14:17.240> hundreds<00:14:17.560> of
the street from here there's hundreds of
the street from here there's hundreds of
people<00:14:17.959> gathered<00:14:18.360> together<00:14:18.800> it<00:14:18.880> was
people gathered together it was
people gathered together it was
technologists<00:14:20.079> and<00:14:20.279> humanists<00:14:21.000> at<00:14:21.120> that<00:14:21.279> big
technologists and humanists at that big
technologists and humanists at that big
biblio<00:14:22.320> Tech<00:14:22.560> conference<00:14:23.360> and<00:14:23.480> they<00:14:23.639> gathered
biblio Tech conference and they gathered
biblio Tech conference and they gathered
together<00:14:24.360> because<00:14:24.639> the<00:14:24.800> technologist<00:14:25.560> wanted
together because the technologist wanted
together because the technologist wanted
to<00:14:26.040> learn<00:14:26.839> what<00:14:26.959> it<00:14:27.040> would<00:14:27.199> be<00:14:27.360> like<00:14:27.600> to<00:14:27.759> think
to learn what it would be like to think
to learn what it would be like to think
from<00:14:28.079> a<00:14:28.199> Humanity<00:14:28.959> perspective<00:14:29.600> you<00:14:29.720> have
from a Humanity perspective you have
from a Humanity perspective you have
someone<00:14:30.120> from<00:14:30.360> Google<00:14:30.759> talking<00:14:31.040> to<00:14:31.160> somebody
someone from Google talking to somebody
someone from Google talking to somebody
who<00:14:31.959> does<00:14:32.199> comparative<00:14:32.720> literature<00:14:33.639> you're
who does comparative literature you're
who does comparative literature you're
thinking<00:14:34.040> about<00:14:34.399> the<00:14:34.560> relevance<00:14:35.000> of<00:14:35.240> 17th
thinking about the relevance of 17th
thinking about the relevance of 17th
century<00:14:36.040> French<00:14:36.360> theater<00:14:36.839> how<00:14:36.920> does<00:14:37.040> that
century French theater how does that
century French theater how does that
bear<00:14:37.440> upon<00:14:37.680> Venture<00:14:38.120> Capital<00:14:38.639> right<00:14:39.040> well
bear upon Venture Capital right well
bear upon Venture Capital right well
that's<00:14:39.399> interesting<00:14:40.000> that's<00:14:40.120> a<00:14:40.320> different
that's interesting that's a different
that's interesting that's a different
way<00:14:40.720> of<00:14:40.880> thinking<00:14:41.560> and<00:14:41.720> when<00:14:41.839> you<00:14:42.040> think<00:14:42.240> in
way of thinking and when you think in
way of thinking and when you think in
that<00:14:42.600> way<00:14:42.959> you<00:14:43.120> become<00:14:43.480> more<00:14:43.839> sensitive<00:14:44.600> to
that way you become more sensitive to
that way you become more sensitive to
the<00:14:44.959> human<00:14:45.720> considerations<00:14:46.720> which<00:14:46.839> are
the human considerations which are
the human considerations which are
crucial<00:14:47.600> to<00:14:47.839> making<00:14:48.440> ethical<00:14:49.240> decisions<00:14:50.240> so
crucial to making ethical decisions so
crucial to making ethical decisions so
imagine<00:14:51.079> that<00:14:51.320> right<00:14:51.560> now<00:14:52.199> you<00:14:52.399> went<00:14:52.720> and<00:14:52.800> you
imagine that right now you went and you
imagine that right now you went and you
found<00:14:53.160> your<00:14:53.360> musician<00:14:53.800> friend<00:14:54.279> and<00:14:54.360> you're
found your musician friend and you're
found your musician friend and you're
telling<00:14:54.839> them<00:14:55.000> what<00:14:55.120> we're<00:14:55.320> talking<00:14:55.639> about
telling them what we're talking about
telling them what we're talking about
you<00:14:56.199> know<00:14:56.440> about<00:14:56.600> our<00:14:56.720> whole<00:14:56.920> data<00:14:57.199> Revolution
you know about our whole data Revolution
you know about our whole data Revolution
all<00:14:57.759> this<00:14:57.880> maybe<00:14:58.120> even<00:14:58.480> like<00:14:58.759> hum<00:14:59.040> a<00:14:59.120> few<00:14:59.320> bars
all this maybe even like hum a few bars
all this maybe even like hum a few bars
of<00:14:59.720> our<00:14:59.920> theme
of our theme
of our theme
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
music<00:15:03.759> well<00:15:04.079> your<00:15:04.279> musician<00:15:04.720> friend<00:15:05.320> will
music well your musician friend will
music well your musician friend will
stop<00:15:05.720> you<00:15:05.839> and<00:15:05.920> say<00:15:06.079> you<00:15:06.199> know<00:15:07.040> the<00:15:07.240> theme
stop you and say you know the theme
stop you and say you know the theme
music<00:15:08.040> for<00:15:08.199> your<00:15:08.320> data<00:15:09.000> Revolution<00:15:10.000> that's<00:15:10.160> an
music for your data Revolution that's an
music for your data Revolution that's an
opera<00:15:11.639> that's<00:15:11.839> vogner<00:15:12.240> it's<00:15:12.519> based<00:15:12.759> on<00:15:12.880> Norse
opera that's vogner it's based on Norse
opera that's vogner it's based on Norse
Legend<00:15:13.720> it's<00:15:14.360> gods<00:15:14.720> and<00:15:14.920> mythical<00:15:15.360> creatures
Legend it's gods and mythical creatures
Legend it's gods and mythical creatures
fighting<00:15:16.639> over<00:15:17.040> magical<00:15:17.800> jewelry<00:15:19.199> um<00:15:20.199> that's
fighting over magical jewelry um that's
fighting over magical jewelry um that's
interesting<00:15:22.320> now<00:15:23.199> it's<00:15:23.440> also<00:15:24.199> a<00:15:24.440> beautiful
interesting now it's also a beautiful
interesting now it's also a beautiful
Opera<00:15:26.160> and<00:15:26.279> we're<00:15:26.519> moved<00:15:27.000> by<00:15:27.199> that<00:15:27.600> Opera
Opera and we're moved by that Opera
Opera and we're moved by that Opera
we're<00:15:28.839> moved<00:15:29.279> because<00:15:30.160> it's<00:15:30.360> about<00:15:30.519> the
we're moved because it's about the
we're moved because it's about the
battle<00:15:31.040> between<00:15:31.399> good<00:15:31.600> and<00:15:31.880> evil<00:15:32.880> about<00:15:33.199> right
battle between good and evil about right
battle between good and evil about right
and<00:15:33.639> wrong<00:15:34.480> and<00:15:34.639> we<00:15:34.920> care<00:15:35.680> about<00:15:35.959> right<00:15:36.120> and
and wrong and we care about right and
and wrong and we care about right and
wrong<00:15:37.000> we<00:15:37.199> care<00:15:37.959> what<00:15:38.199> happens<00:15:38.600> in<00:15:38.759> that<00:15:39.199> Opera
wrong we care what happens in that Opera
wrong we care what happens in that Opera
we<00:15:40.399> care<00:15:40.639> what<00:15:40.759> happens<00:15:41.040> in<00:15:41.240> Apocalypse<00:15:41.880> Now
we care what happens in Apocalypse Now
we care what happens in Apocalypse Now
and<00:15:42.759> we<00:15:42.959> certainly<00:15:43.440> care<00:15:44.040> what<00:15:44.199> happens<00:15:44.680> with
and we certainly care what happens with
and we certainly care what happens with
our
our
our
Technologies<00:15:46.959> we<00:15:47.120> have<00:15:47.360> so<00:15:47.600> much<00:15:47.920> power<00:15:48.440> today
Technologies we have so much power today
Technologies we have so much power today
it<00:15:49.560> is<00:15:49.720> up<00:15:49.880> to<00:15:50.040> us<00:15:50.240> to<00:15:50.360> figure<00:15:50.600> out<00:15:50.759> what<00:15:50.880> to<00:15:51.040> do
it is up to us to figure out what to do
it is up to us to figure out what to do
and<00:15:52.079> that's<00:15:52.279> the<00:15:52.360> good
and that's the good
and that's the good
news<00:15:54.079> we're<00:15:54.319> the<00:15:54.480> ones<00:15:54.920> writing<00:15:55.360> this<00:15:55.560> Opera
news we're the ones writing this Opera
news we're the ones writing this Opera
this<00:15:56.680> is<00:15:56.880> our<00:15:57.360> movie<00:15:58.360> we<00:15:58.759> figure<00:15:59.000> out<00:15:59.199> what
this is our movie we figure out what
this is our movie we figure out what
will<00:15:59.519> happen<00:15:59.800> with<00:15:59.920> this<00:16:00.560> technology<00:16:01.560> we
will happen with this technology we
will happen with this technology we
determine<00:16:02.519> how<00:16:02.759> this<00:16:02.880> will<00:16:03.079> all
determine how this will all
determine how this will all
end<00:16:05.079> thank
end thank
end thank
[Applause]
[Applause]
[Applause]
[Music]
you
Damon Horowitz, TED, TEDx, TEDxSiliconValley, innovation, invention, morality, ethics, philosophy, TED-Ed, TED, Ed’, TEDEducation
