Behind the Great Firewall of China - Michael Anti
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
[Applause]
[Applause]
[Applause]
in<00:00:16.440> the<00:00:16.640> past<00:00:16.840> several<00:00:17.279> days<00:00:18.119> I<00:00:18.240> heard<00:00:18.560> people
in the past several days I heard people
in the past several days I heard people
talking<00:00:19.240> about<00:00:19.560> China<00:00:20.560> and<00:00:20.760> also<00:00:21.039> I<00:00:21.199> talked<00:00:21.519> to
talking about China and also I talked to
talking about China and also I talked to
friends<00:00:22.359> about<00:00:22.680> China<00:00:23.480> and<00:00:23.640> Chinese<00:00:24.199> internet
friends about China and Chinese internet
friends about China and Chinese internet
something<00:00:25.560> is<00:00:25.760> very<00:00:26.000> challenging<00:00:26.519> to<00:00:26.720> me<00:00:27.439> I
something is very challenging to me I
something is very challenging to me I
want<00:00:27.760> to<00:00:28.760> make<00:00:29.039> my<00:00:29.199> friends<00:00:29.560> still<00:00:30.279> understand
want to make my friends still understand
want to make my friends still understand
China<00:00:32.239> is<00:00:33.000> complicated<00:00:34.000> so<00:00:34.200> I<00:00:34.360> always<00:00:34.680> want<00:00:34.840> to
China is complicated so I always want to
China is complicated so I always want to
tell<00:00:35.239> the<00:00:35.440> story<00:00:35.840> like<00:00:36.360> one<00:00:36.640> hand<00:00:37.000> it<00:00:37.120> is<00:00:37.480> there
tell the story like one hand it is there
tell the story like one hand it is there
the<00:00:38.200> other<00:00:38.440> hand<00:00:38.680> is<00:00:38.920> that<00:00:39.719> you<00:00:39.920> can't<00:00:40.280> just
the other hand is that you can't just
the other hand is that you can't just
tell<00:00:41.160> one<00:00:41.520> side<00:00:41.920> story<00:00:42.920> I<00:00:43.079> give<00:00:43.239> you<00:00:43.480> example
tell one side story I give you example
tell one side story I give you example
China<00:00:44.440> is<00:00:44.559> a<00:00:44.760> brick<00:00:45.120> Country<00:00:46.079> Brick<00:00:46.480> country
China is a brick Country Brick country
China is a brick Country Brick country
means<00:00:47.559> Brazil<00:00:48.559> Russia<00:00:49.239> India<00:00:49.920> and<00:00:50.239> China<00:00:51.079> this
means Brazil Russia India and China this
means Brazil Russia India and China this
emerging<00:00:52.120> economy<00:00:52.840> really<00:00:53.680> is<00:00:54.199> helping
emerging economy really is helping
emerging economy really is helping
Revival<00:00:55.399> of<00:00:55.559> the<00:00:55.760> world<00:00:56.079> economy<00:00:57.000> but<00:00:57.199> at<00:00:57.320> the
Revival of the world economy but at the
Revival of the world economy but at the
same<00:00:57.760> time<00:00:58.640> on<00:00:58.800> the<00:00:58.960> other<00:00:59.199> hand
same time on the other hand
same time on the other hand
China<00:01:00.960> is<00:01:01.079> a<00:01:01.359> sick<00:01:02.120> country<00:01:03.120> the<00:01:03.440> the
China is a sick country the the
China is a sick country the the
terminology<00:01:04.479> calleded<00:01:05.000> by<00:01:05.560> Facebook<00:01:06.400> IPO
terminology calleded by Facebook IPO
terminology calleded by Facebook IPO
paper<00:01:08.360> five<00:01:08.720> he<00:01:08.840> said<00:01:09.280> the<00:01:09.479> sick<00:01:09.799> country
paper five he said the sick country
paper five he said the sick country
means<00:01:11.040> Syria<00:01:12.119> Iran<00:01:13.119> China<00:01:13.880> and<00:01:14.080> North<00:01:14.400> Korea
means Syria Iran China and North Korea
means Syria Iran China and North Korea
the<00:01:15.360> four<00:01:15.640> countries<00:01:16.600> have<00:01:16.840> no<00:01:17.200> access<00:01:17.600> to
the four countries have no access to
the four countries have no access to
Facebook<00:01:20.079> so<00:01:20.400> basically<00:01:21.040> China<00:01:21.600> is<00:01:21.720> a<00:01:21.960> sick
Facebook so basically China is a sick
Facebook so basically China is a sick
break<00:01:23.720> country<00:01:24.720> another<00:01:25.400> project<00:01:25.880> was<00:01:26.079> build
break country another project was build
break country another project was build
to<00:01:27.079> watch<00:01:27.640> China<00:01:28.159> and<00:01:28.360> Chinese<00:01:28.840> internet<00:01:29.520> but
to watch China and Chinese internet but
to watch China and Chinese internet but
now<00:01:29.960> now<00:01:30.119> today<00:01:30.520> I<00:01:30.640> want<00:01:30.840> to<00:01:31.119> tell<00:01:31.360> you<00:01:31.960> my
now now today I want to tell you my
now now today I want to tell you my
personal<00:01:33.840> observation<00:01:34.799> in<00:01:34.920> the<00:01:35.119> past<00:01:35.360> sever
personal observation in the past sever
personal observation in the past sever
years<00:01:36.560> from<00:01:37.280> that<00:01:37.840> war<00:01:38.840> so<00:01:39.320> if<00:01:39.479> you<00:01:39.640> are<00:01:39.799> a<00:01:40.040> fan
years from that war so if you are a fan
years from that war so if you are a fan
of<00:01:40.479> the<00:01:40.640> game<00:01:40.840> of<00:01:41.040> thron<00:01:41.640> you<00:01:41.880> definitely<00:01:42.280> know
of the game of thron you definitely know
of the game of thron you definitely know
how<00:01:43.479> important<00:01:44.280> a<00:01:44.479> big<00:01:44.680> war<00:01:45.240> for<00:01:45.600> Old<00:01:46.240> Kingdom
how important a big war for Old Kingdom
how important a big war for Old Kingdom
it<00:01:47.640> prevent<00:01:48.479> weird<00:01:48.960> things<00:01:49.600> from<00:01:49.840> the
it prevent weird things from the
it prevent weird things from the
north<00:01:52.240> same<00:01:52.640> was<00:01:52.840> true<00:01:53.119> for<00:01:53.840> China<00:01:54.840> in<00:01:54.960> the
north same was true for China in the
north same was true for China in the
north<00:01:55.600> there<00:01:55.719> was<00:01:55.880> a<00:01:56.240> great<00:01:56.600> War
north there was a great War
north there was a great War
Junction<00:01:59.000> it<00:01:59.399> protect<00:01:59.960> China<00:02:00.360> from<00:02:00.680> Invaders
Junction it protect China from Invaders
Junction it protect China from Invaders
for<00:02:01.960> 2,000<00:02:02.840> years<00:02:03.799> but<00:02:03.960> China<00:02:04.360> also<00:02:04.640> have<00:02:04.840> a
for 2,000 years but China also have a
for 2,000 years but China also have a
great<00:02:06.399> fire
great fire
great fire
War<00:02:08.360> that's<00:02:08.560> the<00:02:08.759> biggest<00:02:09.319> Digital<00:02:09.879> Boundary
War that's the biggest Digital Boundary
War that's the biggest Digital Boundary
in<00:02:10.599> the<00:02:10.759> whole<00:02:11.040> world<00:02:12.040> it's<00:02:12.200> not<00:02:12.440> only<00:02:12.760> to
in the whole world it's not only to
in the whole world it's not only to
defend<00:02:14.160> Chinese<00:02:14.640> regime<00:02:15.120> from<00:02:15.400> the<00:02:15.560> overc
defend Chinese regime from the overc
defend Chinese regime from the overc
from<00:02:16.800> the<00:02:17.120> universal<00:02:17.760> value<00:02:18.599> but<00:02:18.840> also
from the universal value but also
from the universal value but also
prevent<00:02:20.040> Chinese<00:02:20.560> own<00:02:20.800> citizen<00:02:21.440> to<00:02:21.760> access
prevent Chinese own citizen to access
prevent Chinese own citizen to access
the<00:02:22.319> global<00:02:22.599> free<00:02:23.360> internet<00:02:24.360> and<00:02:24.640> even
the global free internet and even
the global free internet and even
separate<00:02:25.760> themselves<00:02:26.440> into<00:02:26.840> blocks<00:02:27.599> not
separate themselves into blocks not
separate themselves into blocks not
United<00:02:29.440> so
United so
United so
basically<00:02:31.000> internet<00:02:31.720> has<00:02:31.959> two<00:02:32.360> internets<00:02:33.360> one
basically internet has two internets one
basically internet has two internets one
is<00:02:34.120> the<00:02:34.360> internet<00:02:35.160> the<00:02:35.319> other<00:02:35.640> is<00:02:36.080> the<00:02:36.239> China
is the internet the other is the China
is the internet the other is the China
net<00:02:38.200> but<00:02:38.680> if<00:02:38.840> you<00:02:39.040> think<00:02:39.360> the<00:02:39.519> China<00:02:39.879> net<00:02:40.440> is
net but if you think the China net is
net but if you think the China net is
something<00:02:41.640> like<00:02:42.280> a<00:02:43.280> dead<00:02:43.640> land<00:02:44.200> Roost<00:02:44.720> land<00:02:45.480> I
something like a dead land Roost land I
something like a dead land Roost land I
think<00:02:45.800> is
think is
think is
wrong<00:02:47.840> but<00:02:48.319> we<00:02:48.560> also<00:02:49.239> use<00:02:49.760> very<00:02:50.040> simple
wrong but we also use very simple
wrong but we also use very simple
metaphor<00:02:51.800> the<00:02:52.000> cat<00:02:52.239> and<00:02:52.360> the<00:02:52.440> mouse<00:02:52.840> game<00:02:53.440> to
metaphor the cat and the mouse game to
metaphor the cat and the mouse game to
describe<00:02:54.519> in<00:02:54.640> the<00:02:54.879> past<00:02:55.239> 15<00:02:55.959> years<00:02:56.959> the
describe in the past 15 years the
describe in the past 15 years the
continuing<00:02:58.000> fight<00:02:58.519> between<00:02:59.159> Chinese
continuing fight between Chinese
continuing fight between Chinese
censorship<00:03:01.159> government<00:03:01.560> censorship<00:03:02.200> the<00:03:02.440> cat
censorship government censorship the cat
censorship government censorship the cat
and<00:03:03.680> the<00:03:03.799> Chinese<00:03:04.239> internet<00:03:04.879> users<00:03:05.879> that<00:03:06.040> mean
and the Chinese internet users that mean
and the Chinese internet users that mean
us<00:03:07.560> the
us the
us the
mouse<00:03:09.799> but<00:03:10.319> sometimes<00:03:10.840> this<00:03:11.040> kind<00:03:11.239> of<00:03:11.400> a
mouse but sometimes this kind of a
mouse but sometimes this kind of a
metaphor<00:03:12.239> is<00:03:12.400> too<00:03:12.640> simple<00:03:13.480> so<00:03:13.799> today<00:03:14.200> I<00:03:14.319> want
metaphor is too simple so today I want
metaphor is too simple so today I want
to<00:03:14.799> upgrade<00:03:15.400> it<00:03:15.920> to<00:03:16.280> 2.0
to upgrade it to 2.0
to upgrade it to 2.0
version<00:03:19.239> in<00:03:19.440> China<00:03:19.799> we<00:03:19.959> have<00:03:20.239> 500<00:03:20.920> million
version in China we have 500 million
version in China we have 500 million
internet<00:03:21.959> users<00:03:22.959> that's<00:03:23.400> biggest<00:03:24.000> population
internet users that's biggest population
internet users that's biggest population
of<00:03:24.720> natien<00:03:25.360> Internet<00:03:25.799> users<00:03:26.239> in<00:03:26.360> the<00:03:26.519> whole
of natien Internet users in the whole
of natien Internet users in the whole
world<00:03:28.239> so<00:03:29.239> if<00:03:29.799> even<00:03:30.200> Chinese<00:03:30.720> is<00:03:30.840> a<00:03:31.280> totally
world so if even Chinese is a totally
world so if even Chinese is a totally
censored<00:03:32.319> internet<00:03:32.799> but<00:03:33.000> still<00:03:33.480> Chinese
censored internet but still Chinese
censored internet but still Chinese
internet<00:03:34.360> Society<00:03:35.040> is<00:03:35.239> really<00:03:35.680> booming<00:03:36.680> how
internet Society is really booming how
internet Society is really booming how
make<00:03:37.480> it<00:03:38.239> it's<00:03:38.439> simple<00:03:39.200> you<00:03:39.400> have<00:03:39.840> Google<00:03:40.840> we
make it it's simple you have Google we
make it it's simple you have Google we
have<00:03:41.560> Buu<00:03:42.560> you<00:03:42.760> have<00:03:42.959> Twitter<00:03:43.920> we<00:03:44.080> have<00:03:44.640> weo
have Buu you have Twitter we have weo
have Buu you have Twitter we have weo
you<00:03:45.840> have<00:03:46.040> Facebook<00:03:46.959> we<00:03:47.120> have<00:03:47.480> renen<00:03:48.480> you<00:03:48.680> have
you have Facebook we have renen you have
you have Facebook we have renen you have
YouTube<00:03:50.120> we<00:03:50.280> have<00:03:50.599> yuku<00:03:51.280> and
YouTube we have yuku and
YouTube we have yuku and
Twitter<00:03:53.920> Chinese
Twitter Chinese
Twitter Chinese
government<00:03:56.519> blocked<00:03:57.519> every<00:03:58.280> single
government blocked every single
government blocked every single
International<00:04:00.040> Web<00:04:00.200> Two<00:04:00.439> P<00:04:00.879> services<00:04:01.760> and<00:04:02.000> we
International Web Two P services and we
International Web Two P services and we
Chinese<00:04:02.840> copycat
Chinese copycat
Chinese copycat
everyone<00:04:06.120> so<00:04:06.680> that's<00:04:07.040> kind<00:04:07.319> of<00:04:08.319> the<00:04:08.519> thing<00:04:08.720> I
everyone so that's kind of the thing I
everyone so that's kind of the thing I
called<00:04:09.280> SM<00:04:09.720> censorship<00:04:10.720> so<00:04:11.200> that's<00:04:11.480> not<00:04:11.840> only
called SM censorship so that's not only
called SM censorship so that's not only
to<00:04:13.120> censor<00:04:13.560> you<00:04:14.519> sometimes<00:04:15.079> that's<00:04:15.799> Chinese
to censor you sometimes that's Chinese
to censor you sometimes that's Chinese
National<00:04:17.040> internet<00:04:17.479> policy<00:04:17.799> is<00:04:18.000> very<00:04:18.239> simple
National internet policy is very simple
National internet policy is very simple
block<00:04:19.840> and<00:04:20.479> clone<00:04:21.479> on<00:04:21.680> the<00:04:21.880> one<00:04:22.120> hand<00:04:23.120> he<00:04:23.280> want
block and clone on the one hand he want
block and clone on the one hand he want
to<00:04:23.759> satisfy<00:04:24.360> people's<00:04:24.720> need<00:04:25.000> of<00:04:25.199> social
to satisfy people's need of social
to satisfy people's need of social
network<00:04:26.199> which<00:04:26.360> is<00:04:26.560> very<00:04:26.800> important<00:04:27.360> people
network which is very important people
network which is very important people
really<00:04:27.960> love<00:04:28.320> social<00:04:28.639> networking<00:04:29.639> but<00:04:29.720> on<00:04:29.840> the
really love social networking but on the
really love social networking but on the
other<00:04:30.280> hand<00:04:30.960> they<00:04:31.120> want<00:04:31.280> to<00:04:31.479> keep<00:04:31.720> the<00:04:31.880> server
other hand they want to keep the server
other hand they want to keep the server
in<00:04:32.840> Beijing<00:04:33.600> so<00:04:33.880> they<00:04:34.000> can<00:04:34.320> access<00:04:34.720> the<00:04:34.919> data
in Beijing so they can access the data
in Beijing so they can access the data
anytime<00:04:36.120> they<00:04:36.320> want<00:04:37.280> that's<00:04:37.639> also<00:04:37.880> the<00:04:38.039> reason
anytime they want that's also the reason
anytime they want that's also the reason
Google<00:04:39.360> was<00:04:39.800> pulled<00:04:40.120> out<00:04:40.320> from<00:04:40.560> China<00:04:41.039> because
Google was pulled out from China because
Google was pulled out from China because
they<00:04:41.479> can't<00:04:41.880> accept<00:04:42.360> the<00:04:42.600> fact<00:04:43.120> Chinese
they can't accept the fact Chinese
they can't accept the fact Chinese
government<00:04:43.840> want<00:04:44.080> to<00:04:44.320> keep<00:04:44.720> the
server<00:04:48.479> sometimes<00:04:49.280> the<00:04:49.639> Arab<00:04:50.000> dictators
server sometimes the Arab dictators
server sometimes the Arab dictators
didn't<00:04:51.280> understand<00:04:51.720> these<00:04:51.919> two<00:04:52.160> hands<00:04:53.080> for
didn't understand these two hands for
didn't understand these two hands for
example<00:04:53.759> Mubarak<00:04:54.759> he<00:04:54.919> shut<00:04:55.280> down<00:04:55.800> the
example Mubarak he shut down the
example Mubarak he shut down the
internet<00:04:57.080> he<00:04:57.360> want<00:04:57.600> to<00:04:57.800> prevent<00:04:58.199> neens<00:04:58.800> to
internet he want to prevent neens to
internet he want to prevent neens to
criticize<00:04:59.440> him
criticize him
criticize him
but<00:05:00.560> once<00:05:01.280> Nan<00:05:01.880> can't<00:05:02.120> go<00:05:02.320> online<00:05:03.199> they<00:05:03.400> go<00:05:03.520> on
but once Nan can't go online they go on
but once Nan can't go online they go on
street<00:05:05.759> and<00:05:06.720> now<00:05:07.360> the<00:05:07.759> result<00:05:08.120> is<00:05:08.400> very<00:05:08.639> simple
street and now the result is very simple
street and now the result is very simple
we<00:05:09.199> all<00:05:09.520> know<00:05:10.240> Mubarak<00:05:11.240> is<00:05:11.560> technically
we all know Mubarak is technically
we all know Mubarak is technically
dead<00:05:14.600> but
dead but
dead but
also<00:05:16.560> Ben<00:05:16.840> Ani<00:05:17.560> Tunisia<00:05:18.360> president<00:05:19.360> didn't
also Ben Ani Tunisia president didn't
also Ben Ani Tunisia president didn't
follow<00:05:20.199> the<00:05:20.319> second<00:05:20.680> rule<00:05:21.160> that<00:05:21.280> means<00:05:22.080> keep
follow the second rule that means keep
follow the second rule that means keep
the<00:05:22.479> server<00:05:23.319> in<00:05:23.600> your<00:05:24.000> hand<00:05:25.000> he<00:05:25.600> allowed
the server in your hand he allowed
the server in your hand he allowed
Facebook<00:05:27.520> a<00:05:27.800> us-based<00:05:28.479> services
Facebook a us-based services
Facebook a us-based services
service<00:05:31.080> to<00:05:31.360> continue<00:05:31.840> stay<00:05:32.199> on<00:05:33.199> inside
service to continue stay on inside
service to continue stay on inside
Tunisia<00:05:34.319> so<00:05:34.560> he<00:05:34.759> can't<00:05:35.240> prevented<00:05:36.240> his<00:05:36.400> own
Tunisia so he can't prevented his own
Tunisia so he can't prevented his own
citizens<00:05:37.240> to<00:05:37.520> post<00:05:38.240> critical<00:05:38.720> video<00:05:39.120> against
citizens to post critical video against
citizens to post critical video against
his
his
his
corruption<00:05:41.400> the<00:05:41.560> same<00:05:41.800> thing<00:05:42.319> happened<00:05:43.319> he
corruption the same thing happened he
corruption the same thing happened he
was<00:05:43.759> the<00:05:43.919> first<00:05:44.319> to<00:05:44.600> tobert<00:05:45.319> joing<00:05:45.680> the<00:05:45.759> Arab
was the first to tobert joing the Arab
was the first to tobert joing the Arab
spray<00:05:47.680> but<00:05:47.880> those<00:05:48.600> two<00:05:49.039> very<00:05:49.600> smart<00:05:50.520> you<00:05:50.680> know
spray but those two very smart you know
spray but those two very smart you know
National<00:05:51.400> censorship<00:05:52.000> policy<00:05:52.759> didn't
National censorship policy didn't
National censorship policy didn't
prevent<00:05:55.080> Chinese<00:05:55.720> social<00:05:56.080> media<00:05:56.639> become<00:05:57.080> a
prevent Chinese social media become a
prevent Chinese social media become a
really<00:05:57.880> public<00:05:58.400> spere<00:05:58.960> a<00:05:59.160> b<00:05:59.479> feere<00:05:59.759> of<00:06:00.039> public
really public spere a b feere of public
really public spere a b feere of public
opinion<00:06:01.440> and<00:06:01.840> the<00:06:02.039> nightmare<00:06:02.960> of<00:06:03.160> Chinese
opinion and the nightmare of Chinese
opinion and the nightmare of Chinese
officials<00:06:05.160> because<00:06:05.520> we<00:06:05.720> have<00:06:06.280> 300<00:06:06.960> million
officials because we have 300 million
officials because we have 300 million
micro<00:06:07.720> bloggers<00:06:08.280> in<00:06:08.479> China<00:06:09.120> is<00:06:09.319> the<00:06:09.840> entire
micro bloggers in China is the entire
micro bloggers in China is the entire
population<00:06:11.240> of<00:06:11.520> United<00:06:12.319> States<00:06:13.319> so<00:06:13.599> when
population of United States so when
population of United States so when
these<00:06:14.479> 300<00:06:15.039> million<00:06:15.440> people<00:06:15.759> Michel<00:06:16.120> blogger
these 300 million people Michel blogger
these 300 million people Michel blogger
even<00:06:17.560> they<00:06:17.800> block<00:06:18.800> the<00:06:18.960> tweet<00:06:19.400> in<00:06:19.560> a<00:06:19.880> censored
even they block the tweet in a censored
even they block the tweet in a censored
platform<00:06:22.080> but<00:06:22.280> itself<00:06:22.800> is<00:06:23.000> China<00:06:23.360> L<00:06:23.840> but<00:06:24.000> it
platform but itself is China L but it
platform but itself is China L but it
can<00:06:24.919> create<00:06:25.759> very
can create very
can create very
powerful<00:06:28.120> energy<00:06:28.639> which<00:06:28.800> is<00:06:28.960> never<00:06:29.479> happened
powerful energy which is never happened
powerful energy which is never happened
in<00:06:29.840> the<00:06:29.960> Chinese
in the Chinese
in the Chinese
history<00:06:32.039> 2011<00:06:33.039> the<00:06:33.199> July<00:06:34.120> two<00:06:34.360> briding<00:06:34.759> trains
history 2011 the July two briding trains
history 2011 the July two briding trains
crashed<00:06:36.360> in<00:06:36.560> wo<00:06:37.039> a<00:06:37.199> sou<00:06:37.599> city<00:06:38.319> right<00:06:38.639> after<00:06:38.919> the
crashed in wo a sou city right after the
crashed in wo a sou city right after the
train<00:06:39.400> crash<00:06:40.400> authorities<00:06:41.319> literally<00:06:41.880> want
train crash authorities literally want
train crash authorities literally want
to<00:06:42.680> cover<00:06:43.000> up<00:06:43.240> the<00:06:43.319> train<00:06:43.759> bury<00:06:44.120> the<00:06:44.199> train<00:06:44.960> so
to cover up the train bury the train so
to cover up the train bury the train so
it's<00:06:45.520> anger<00:06:45.919> the<00:06:46.000> Chinese<00:06:46.800> Naes<00:06:47.800> the<00:06:47.960> first
it's anger the Chinese Naes the first
it's anger the Chinese Naes the first
five<00:06:48.639> days<00:06:49.080> after<00:06:49.240> the<00:06:49.360> train<00:06:49.840> crash<00:06:50.840> there
five days after the train crash there
five days after the train crash there
were<00:06:51.639> 10<00:06:52.199> million<00:06:52.919> critism<00:06:53.560> of<00:06:53.680> the<00:06:53.880> posting
were 10 million critism of the posting
were 10 million critism of the posting
on<00:06:55.000> the<00:06:55.160> social<00:06:55.479> media<00:06:56.080> which<00:06:56.319> never<00:06:56.599> happened
on the social media which never happened
on the social media which never happened
in<00:06:57.080> Chinese<00:06:57.440> history<00:06:58.160> and<00:06:58.759> later<00:06:59.400> later<00:06:59.680> this
in Chinese history and later later this
in Chinese history and later later this
year<00:07:00.199> the<00:07:00.360> real<00:07:00.919> Minister<00:07:01.919> was<00:07:02.360> sacked<00:07:03.000> and
year the real Minister was sacked and
year the real Minister was sacked and
sentenced<00:07:03.680> to<00:07:03.840> jail<00:07:04.280> for<00:07:04.479> 10
sentenced to jail for 10
sentenced to jail for 10
years<00:07:07.039> and<00:07:07.360> also<00:07:08.199> very<00:07:09.240> recently<00:07:10.240> very<00:07:10.400> funny
years and also very recently very funny
years and also very recently very funny
debate<00:07:11.440> between<00:07:11.879> the<00:07:12.680> Beijing<00:07:13.680> environment
debate between the Beijing environment
debate between the Beijing environment
Ministry<00:07:15.160> and<00:07:16.080> American<00:07:16.560> Embassy<00:07:17.120> in<00:07:17.680> Beijing
Ministry and American Embassy in Beijing
Ministry and American Embassy in Beijing
because<00:07:19.440> the<00:07:19.639> ministry<00:07:20.319> blame<00:07:21.080> American
because the ministry blame American
because the ministry blame American
Embassy<00:07:21.879> for<00:07:22.160> intervening<00:07:23.360> Chinese<00:07:24.360> internal
Embassy for intervening Chinese internal
Embassy for intervening Chinese internal
politics<00:07:25.560> by<00:07:25.840> disclosing<00:07:26.840> the<00:07:27.000> air<00:07:27.319> quality
politics by disclosing the air quality
politics by disclosing the air quality
data<00:07:28.160> of<00:07:28.319> Beijing
data of Beijing
data of Beijing
so<00:07:30.840> the<00:07:31.039> app<00:07:31.840> is<00:07:32.000> the<00:07:32.160> embassy<00:07:32.759> data<00:07:33.759> the<00:07:33.919> PM
so the app is the embassy data the PM
so the app is the embassy data the PM
2.5<00:07:36.400> he
2.5 he
2.5 he
show<00:07:38.240> 148<00:07:38.960> they<00:07:39.120> show<00:07:39.520> is<00:07:40.520> dangerous<00:07:41.000> for
show 148 they show is dangerous for
show 148 they show is dangerous for
sensitive<00:07:41.840> group<00:07:42.360> so<00:07:43.120> suggestion<00:07:44.039> is<00:07:44.240> not
sensitive group so suggestion is not
sensitive group so suggestion is not
good<00:07:44.639> to<00:07:44.800> go
good to go
good to go
outside<00:07:46.639> but<00:07:47.319> the<00:07:47.680> D<00:07:48.680> is<00:07:48.879> the<00:07:49.440> Ministries<00:07:50.120> data
outside but the D is the Ministries data
outside but the D is the Ministries data
he<00:07:50.680> shows<00:07:51.080> 50<00:07:51.800> he<00:07:51.919> said<00:07:52.199> it's<00:07:52.440> good<00:07:53.240> it's<00:07:53.520> good
he shows 50 he said it's good it's good
he shows 50 he said it's good it's good
to<00:07:53.840> go
to go
to go
outside<00:07:55.639> but<00:07:56.000> 99%<00:07:57.000> of<00:07:57.199> Chinese<00:07:57.639> micro
outside but 99% of Chinese micro
outside but 99% of Chinese micro
bloggers<00:07:58.720> stand<00:07:59.319> firmly<00:08:00.319> on<00:08:00.520> the<00:08:01.120> embassy
bloggers stand firmly on the embassy
bloggers stand firmly on the embassy
side<00:08:02.360> I<00:08:02.479> live<00:08:02.759> in<00:08:02.960> Beijing<00:08:03.800> every<00:08:04.560> day<00:08:05.560> I<00:08:05.800> just
side I live in Beijing every day I just
side I live in Beijing every day I just
watch<00:08:07.560> the<00:08:08.319> American<00:08:08.680> Embassy<00:08:09.199> data<00:08:09.759> to
watch the American Embassy data to
watch the American Embassy data to
decide<00:08:10.800> whether<00:08:11.159> I<00:08:11.240> should<00:08:11.599> open<00:08:11.960> my
window<00:08:16.120> why<00:08:16.599> Chinese<00:08:17.039> social<00:08:17.639> networking
window why Chinese social networking
window why Chinese social networking
even<00:08:18.680> within<00:08:18.960> the<00:08:19.120> censorship<00:08:20.000> is<00:08:20.240> so<00:08:20.840> boming
even within the censorship is so boming
even within the censorship is so boming
part<00:08:22.080> of<00:08:22.159> the<00:08:22.319> reason<00:08:22.560> is<00:08:22.759> Chinese<00:08:23.599> languages
part of the reason is Chinese languages
part of the reason is Chinese languages
you<00:08:24.759> know<00:08:25.759> ttor<00:08:26.159> and<00:08:26.319> trt<00:08:26.639> clones<00:08:27.039> have<00:08:27.199> a<00:08:27.440> kind
you know ttor and trt clones have a kind
you know ttor and trt clones have a kind
of<00:08:27.800> a<00:08:28.080> limitation<00:08:29.000> 14<00:08:29.560> characters<00:08:30.560> but<00:08:30.720> in
of a limitation 14 characters but in
of a limitation 14 characters but in
English<00:08:31.319> it's<00:08:31.479> 20<00:08:31.879> words<00:08:32.800> or<00:08:33.039> a<00:08:33.159> sentence<00:08:33.560> with
English it's 20 words or a sentence with
English it's 20 words or a sentence with
a<00:08:33.800> short<00:08:34.000> link<00:08:34.560> maybe<00:08:34.839> in<00:08:35.000> Germany<00:08:35.599> a<00:08:35.760> German
a short link maybe in Germany a German
a short link maybe in Germany a German
language<00:08:36.479> maybe<00:08:36.760> just
AA
AA
AA
but<00:08:41.919> in<00:08:42.120> Chinese<00:08:42.560> language<00:08:43.000> is<00:08:43.200> really<00:08:44.000> about
but in Chinese language is really about
but in Chinese language is really about
140<00:08:45.480> characters<00:08:46.240> means<00:08:46.680> a<00:08:46.920> paragraph<00:08:47.720> a<00:08:48.279> story
140 characters means a paragraph a story
140 characters means a paragraph a story
you<00:08:49.440> can<00:08:49.680> almost<00:08:50.120> have<00:08:50.399> all<00:08:50.720> the<00:08:51.040> journalistic
you can almost have all the journalistic
you can almost have all the journalistic
elements<00:08:52.640> to<00:08:52.920> there<00:08:53.080> for<00:08:53.279> example<00:08:54.120> this<00:08:54.240> is
elements to there for example this is
elements to there for example this is
the<00:08:54.880> Hamlet<00:08:55.519> of<00:08:55.640> the<00:08:55.959> Shakespeare<00:08:56.959> the<00:08:57.160> same
the Hamlet of the Shakespeare the same
the Hamlet of the Shakespeare the same
content<00:08:58.640> one<00:08:59.200> you<00:08:59.320> can<00:08:59.480> see<00:08:59.839> exactly<00:09:00.519> one
content one you can see exactly one
content one you can see exactly one
Chinese<00:09:01.320> tweet<00:09:02.000> is<00:09:02.240> equal<00:09:02.560> to
Chinese tweet is equal to
Chinese tweet is equal to
3.5<00:09:04.920> English
3.5 English
3.5 English
tweets<00:09:06.920> Chinese<00:09:07.360> is<00:09:07.519> always<00:09:08.040> cheating
tweets Chinese is always cheating
tweets Chinese is always cheating
right<00:09:10.399> so<00:09:10.880> because<00:09:11.200> of<00:09:11.480> this<00:09:11.800> Chinese<00:09:12.399> really
right so because of this Chinese really
right so because of this Chinese really
regard<00:09:13.880> this<00:09:14.320> micro<00:09:14.720> blogging<00:09:15.480> as<00:09:15.600> a<00:09:15.839> media
regard this micro blogging as a media
regard this micro blogging as a media
not<00:09:16.760> only<00:09:17.360> headline<00:09:18.120> to<00:09:18.360> media<00:09:19.320> and<00:09:19.640> also<00:09:20.640> the
not only headline to media and also the
not only headline to media and also the
Clone<00:09:21.680> Signal<00:09:22.160> Company<00:09:22.519> is<00:09:22.920> the<00:09:23.079> guy<00:09:23.399> who
Clone Signal Company is the guy who
Clone Signal Company is the guy who
cloned<00:09:24.120> the<00:09:24.360> Twitter<00:09:25.320> they<00:09:25.480> even<00:09:25.800> has<00:09:25.920> their
cloned the Twitter they even has their
cloned the Twitter they even has their
own<00:09:26.279> name<00:09:26.680> with<00:09:26.959> with<00:09:27.120> weo<00:09:27.519> weo<00:09:27.920> is<00:09:28.120> Chinese
own name with with weo weo is Chinese
own name with with weo weo is Chinese
translation<00:09:28.839> for<00:09:29.200> mic<00:09:29.480> blog<00:09:30.120> it<00:09:30.360> has<00:09:30.519> owned
translation for mic blog it has owned
translation for mic blog it has owned
the<00:09:31.040> Innovation<00:09:31.920> at<00:09:32.200> the<00:09:32.320> commenting<00:09:33.000> area
the Innovation at the commenting area
the Innovation at the commenting area
make<00:09:34.160> the<00:09:34.320> Chinese<00:09:34.800> weor<00:09:35.519> more<00:09:35.800> like<00:09:36.399> Facebook
make the Chinese weor more like Facebook
make the Chinese weor more like Facebook
rather<00:09:37.640> than<00:09:37.880> original<00:09:38.360> Twitter<00:09:39.160> so<00:09:39.640> these
rather than original Twitter so these
rather than original Twitter so these
Innovations<00:09:40.720> and<00:09:40.959> clones<00:09:41.519> as<00:09:41.720> the<00:09:41.839> wo<00:09:42.480> and
Innovations and clones as the wo and
Innovations and clones as the wo and
micro<00:09:43.079> blogging<00:09:43.560> when<00:09:43.720> they<00:09:43.959> come<00:09:44.200> to<00:09:44.440> China
micro blogging when they come to China
micro blogging when they come to China
in<00:09:45.519> 2009<00:09:46.519> the<00:09:47.000> immediately<00:09:47.640> become<00:09:48.120> the<00:09:48.279> media
in 2009 the immediately become the media
in 2009 the immediately become the media
platform<00:09:49.240> itself<00:09:50.000> it<00:09:50.160> become<00:09:50.519> a<00:09:50.680> media
platform itself it become a media
platform itself it become a media
platform<00:09:51.640> of<00:09:51.839> 300<00:09:52.440> million<00:09:53.399> readers<00:09:54.399> it
platform of 300 million readers it
platform of 300 million readers it
become<00:09:55.200> the<00:09:55.440> media<00:09:56.120> if<00:09:56.640> anything<00:09:57.120> not
become the media if anything not
become the media if anything not
mentioned<00:09:57.880> in<00:09:58.079> weo<00:09:58.760> it<00:09:58.880> does<00:09:59.200> not
mentioned in weo it does not
mentioned in weo it does not
appear<00:10:01.160> to<00:10:01.480> exist<00:10:01.839> for<00:10:02.079> Chinese
appear to exist for Chinese
appear to exist for Chinese
public<00:10:04.079> but<00:10:04.279> also<00:10:04.680> Chinese<00:10:05.240> social<00:10:05.560> media<00:10:05.920> is
public but also Chinese social media is
public but also Chinese social media is
really<00:10:06.600> changing<00:10:07.200> Chinese<00:10:08.160> mindset<00:10:09.160> and
really changing Chinese mindset and
really changing Chinese mindset and
Chinese<00:10:09.959> life<00:10:10.600> for<00:10:11.160> example<00:10:12.160> they<00:10:12.320> give<00:10:12.600> the
Chinese life for example they give the
Chinese life for example they give the
voiceless<00:10:13.640> people<00:10:14.120> a<00:10:14.320> China<00:10:14.920> to<00:10:15.200> make<00:10:15.440> your
voiceless people a China to make your
voiceless people a China to make your
voice<00:10:16.160> heard<00:10:17.160> we<00:10:17.399> had<00:10:17.519> a<00:10:17.839> petition<00:10:18.320> system<00:10:18.839> is
voice heard we had a petition system is
voice heard we had a petition system is
a<00:10:19.240> remedy<00:10:20.079> outside<00:10:21.079> the<00:10:21.279> judicial<00:10:21.760> system
a remedy outside the judicial system
a remedy outside the judicial system
because<00:10:23.160> Chinese<00:10:23.519> central<00:10:23.800> government<00:10:24.120> want
because Chinese central government want
because Chinese central government want
to<00:10:24.440> keep<00:10:24.640> a<00:10:24.839> miss<00:10:25.640> the<00:10:25.839> emperor<00:10:26.480> is<00:10:26.760> good<00:10:27.440> but
to keep a miss the emperor is good but
to keep a miss the emperor is good but
all<00:10:27.959> the<00:10:28.120> local<00:10:28.399> officials<00:10:28.760> are<00:10:29.120> sucks<00:10:30.000> so
all the local officials are sucks so
all the local officials are sucks so
that's<00:10:30.480> why<00:10:30.640> the<00:10:30.839> petitioner<00:10:31.720> the<00:10:31.920> victims<00:10:32.360> of
that's why the petitioner the victims of
that's why the petitioner the victims of
the<00:10:32.640> pant<00:10:33.279> went<00:10:33.519> to<00:10:33.760> take<00:10:33.959> the<00:10:34.120> train<00:10:34.399> to
the pant went to take the train to
the pant went to take the train to
Beijing<00:10:35.200> to<00:10:35.399> petition<00:10:35.760> to<00:10:35.920> central
Beijing to petition to central
Beijing to petition to central
government<00:10:36.959> want<00:10:37.440> the<00:10:37.680> emperor<00:10:38.079> want<00:10:38.240> to
government want the emperor want to
government want the emperor want to
settle<00:10:38.760> the<00:10:39.120> problem<00:10:40.120> but<00:10:40.560> when<00:10:40.760> more<00:10:40.959> and
settle the problem but when more and
settle the problem but when more and
more<00:10:41.360> people<00:10:41.839> go<00:10:42.000> to<00:10:42.160> Beijing<00:10:42.680> they<00:10:42.880> also
more people go to Beijing they also
more people go to Beijing they also
cause<00:10:44.279> the<00:10:44.480> risk<00:10:45.000> of<00:10:45.240> Revolution<00:10:46.240> so<00:10:46.519> they
cause the risk of Revolution so they
cause the risk of Revolution so they
sent<00:10:46.920> them<00:10:47.160> back<00:10:47.440> recent<00:10:48.000> years<00:10:48.959> and<00:10:49.200> even
sent them back recent years and even
sent them back recent years and even
some<00:10:49.800> of<00:10:50.320> of<00:10:50.480> them<00:10:50.639> would<00:10:50.880> put<00:10:51.160> into<00:10:51.560> black
some of of them would put into black
some of of them would put into black
jaar<00:10:52.519> but<00:10:52.720> now<00:10:53.360> we<00:10:53.519> have<00:10:53.720> the<00:10:53.880> weo<00:10:54.519> so<00:10:54.720> I<00:10:54.839> called
jaar but now we have the weo so I called
jaar but now we have the weo so I called
weo<00:10:55.600> petition<00:10:56.360> people<00:10:56.680> just<00:10:56.959> use<00:10:57.240> the<00:10:57.360> cell
weo petition people just use the cell
weo petition people just use the cell
phone<00:10:57.880> to<00:10:58.040> tweet<00:10:59.240> so<00:10:59.440> your<00:10:59.600> sad<00:10:59.959> stories<00:11:00.800> by
phone to tweet so your sad stories by
phone to tweet so your sad stories by
some<00:11:01.320> chance<00:11:01.959> your<00:11:02.200> story<00:11:02.519> will<00:11:02.760> be<00:11:02.920> picked<00:11:03.200> up
some chance your story will be picked up
some chance your story will be picked up
by<00:11:03.880> reporters<00:11:04.720> professors<00:11:05.240> or<00:11:05.560> celebrities
by reporters professors or celebrities
by reporters professors or celebrities
one<00:11:06.760> of<00:11:07.000> that<00:11:07.279> is<00:11:07.560> yaan<00:11:08.560> she's<00:11:09.040> most<00:11:09.519> popular
one of that is yaan she's most popular
one of that is yaan she's most popular
micro<00:11:10.360> blogger<00:11:10.880> in<00:11:11.040> China<00:11:11.399> who<00:11:12.160> has<00:11:12.399> about<00:11:13.000> 21
micro blogger in China who has about 21
micro blogger in China who has about 21
million<00:11:14.519> followers<00:11:15.480> they're<00:11:15.680> almost<00:11:16.200> like<00:11:16.600> a
million followers they're almost like a
million followers they're almost like a
national<00:11:18.079> TV<00:11:18.480> station<00:11:19.079> if<00:11:19.279> you<00:11:19.880> st<00:11:20.279> sad<00:11:20.600> story
national TV station if you st sad story
national TV station if you st sad story
will<00:11:21.160> pick<00:11:21.360> up<00:11:21.560> by<00:11:21.760> her<00:11:22.720> so<00:11:23.200> this<00:11:23.600> wo<00:11:24.160> social
will pick up by her so this wo social
will pick up by her so this wo social
media<00:11:25.200> even<00:11:25.839> in<00:11:26.000> the<00:11:26.160> censorship<00:11:27.040> still<00:11:27.839> gave
media even in the censorship still gave
media even in the censorship still gave
Chinese<00:11:28.639> a<00:11:29.040> real<00:11:29.560> chance<00:11:30.560> for<00:11:30.920> 300<00:11:31.519> million
Chinese a real chance for 300 million
Chinese a real chance for 300 million
people<00:11:32.720> every<00:11:33.079> day<00:11:33.440> chatting<00:11:34.040> together
people every day chatting together
people every day chatting together
talking<00:11:35.079> to<00:11:35.480> together<00:11:35.959> it's<00:11:36.200> like<00:11:36.320> a<00:11:36.519> big<00:11:36.800> Tad
talking to together it's like a big Tad
talking to together it's like a big Tad
right<00:11:39.120> but<00:11:39.560> also<00:11:40.160> it<00:11:40.279> is<00:11:40.600> like<00:11:40.880> the<00:11:41.040> first<00:11:41.360> time
right but also it is like the first time
right but also it is like the first time
of<00:11:41.880> public<00:11:42.200> sphere<00:11:43.079> happened<00:11:43.440> in<00:11:43.600> China
of public sphere happened in China
of public sphere happened in China
Chinese<00:11:45.000> people<00:11:45.600> start<00:11:45.920> to<00:11:46.120> learn<00:11:46.519> how<00:11:46.680> to
Chinese people start to learn how to
Chinese people start to learn how to
negotiate<00:11:48.360> and<00:11:48.800> talk<00:11:49.040> to<00:11:49.600> people<00:11:50.600> but<00:11:51.040> also
negotiate and talk to people but also
negotiate and talk to people but also
the<00:11:52.279> cat<00:11:52.720> the<00:11:52.920> sensorship<00:11:53.399> is<00:11:53.560> not<00:11:53.760> sleeping
the cat the sensorship is not sleeping
the cat the sensorship is not sleeping
it's<00:11:54.959> so<00:11:55.360> hard<00:11:56.000> to<00:11:56.240> post<00:11:56.959> some<00:11:57.240> sensitive
it's so hard to post some sensitive
it's so hard to post some sensitive
words<00:11:57.959> in<00:11:58.040> the<00:11:58.160> Chinese<00:11:58.480> we<00:11:58.760> for<00:11:58.920> for<00:11:59.000> example
words in the Chinese we for for example
words in the Chinese we for for example
you<00:11:59.399> can't<00:11:59.760> post<00:12:00.519> the<00:12:00.720> name<00:12:00.959> of<00:12:01.120> the
you can't post the name of the
you can't post the name of the
president<00:12:02.880> huin<00:12:03.880> and<00:12:04.079> also<00:12:04.360> you<00:12:04.519> can't<00:12:04.839> post
president huin and also you can't post
president huin and also you can't post
the<00:12:05.600> city<00:12:05.800> of<00:12:06.160> chonging<00:12:07.160> name<00:12:07.839> and<00:12:08.279> until
the city of chonging name and until
the city of chonging name and until
recently<00:12:09.200> you<00:12:09.320> can't<00:12:09.560> search<00:12:09.920> the<00:12:10.040> surname<00:12:10.480> of
recently you can't search the surname of
recently you can't search the surname of
top<00:12:11.000> top
top top
top top
leaders<00:12:12.959> so<00:12:13.639> the<00:12:13.800> Chinese<00:12:14.279> are<00:12:14.519> very<00:12:14.720> good
leaders so the Chinese are very good
leaders so the Chinese are very good
that<00:12:15.240> there<00:12:15.600> palms<00:12:16.600> and<00:12:17.279> alternative<00:12:18.279> wording
that there palms and alternative wording
that there palms and alternative wording
and<00:12:19.079> even<00:12:19.360> memes<00:12:20.199> the<00:12:20.360> even<00:12:20.920> Nam<00:12:21.920> you<00:12:22.040> know<00:12:22.240> use
and even memes the even Nam you know use
and even memes the even Nam you know use
the<00:12:22.920> name<00:12:23.320> of<00:12:23.560> this<00:12:23.959> world<00:12:24.320> changing<00:12:25.320> batter
the name of this world changing batter
the name of this world changing batter
between<00:12:26.040> the<00:12:26.199> grma<00:12:27.199> horse<00:12:27.720> and<00:12:27.920> River<00:12:28.279> craft
between the grma horse and River craft
between the grma horse and River craft
grma<00:12:29.440> horse<00:12:29.839> is<00:12:30.079> T<00:12:30.839> it's<00:12:30.959> the<00:12:31.120> photogram<00:12:32.079> for
grma horse is T it's the photogram for
grma horse is T it's the photogram for
it's<00:12:34.440> n
call<00:12:39.800> River<00:12:40.199> crap<00:12:40.720> is<00:12:41.600> is<00:12:41.760> the<00:12:41.880> phonogram<00:12:42.480> for
call River crap is is the phonogram for
call River crap is is the phonogram for
harmonization<00:12:44.240> for<00:12:44.639> sensorship<00:12:45.600> so<00:12:45.920> that's
harmonization for sensorship so that's
harmonization for sensorship so that's
kind<00:12:46.560> of<00:12:46.760> Aima<00:12:47.480> versus<00:12:48.480> the<00:12:49.079> her<00:12:49.920> that's<00:12:50.160> very
kind of Aima versus the her that's very
kind of Aima versus the her that's very
good<00:12:51.120> but<00:12:52.120> so<00:12:52.480> that's<00:12:52.959> in<00:12:53.320> when<00:12:53.519> some<00:12:53.839> very
good but so that's in when some very
good but so that's in when some very
political<00:12:55.360> exciting<00:12:55.839> moment<00:12:56.240> happened<00:12:57.160> you
political exciting moment happened you
political exciting moment happened you
can<00:12:57.839> see<00:12:58.320> on<00:12:58.440> the<00:12:58.560> way<00:12:59.079> you<00:12:59.199> still<00:12:59.519> a<00:12:59.639> lot<00:12:59.839> of
can see on the way you still a lot of
can see on the way you still a lot of
very<00:13:00.639> weird<00:13:01.160> stories<00:13:02.160> happened<00:13:03.199> weird
very weird stories happened weird
very weird stories happened weird
phrases<00:13:04.720> and<00:13:05.000> words<00:13:05.800> even<00:13:06.079> you<00:13:06.240> have<00:13:06.399> a<00:13:06.600> PhD<00:13:07.120> of
phrases and words even you have a PhD of
phrases and words even you have a PhD of
Chinese<00:13:07.800> language<00:13:08.160> you<00:13:08.320> can't<00:13:08.880> understand
Chinese language you can't understand
Chinese language you can't understand
them<00:13:10.600> but<00:13:10.880> you<00:13:11.000> can<00:13:11.160> you<00:13:11.399> expect<00:13:11.839> more<00:13:12.399> no
them but you can you expect more no
them but you can you expect more no
because<00:13:13.519> Chinese<00:13:13.959> signal<00:13:14.399> weor<00:13:15.120> one<00:13:15.399> he<00:13:15.600> was
because Chinese signal weor one he was
because Chinese signal weor one he was
funded<00:13:16.320> is<00:13:17.000> exactly<00:13:17.519> one<00:13:17.800> month<00:13:18.360> after<00:13:18.839> the
funded is exactly one month after the
funded is exactly one month after the
official<00:13:19.720> blocking<00:13:20.279> of<00:13:20.519> twitter.com<00:13:21.519> that
official blocking of twitter.com that
official blocking of twitter.com that
means<00:13:22.279> from<00:13:22.519> the<00:13:22.680> very<00:13:23.040> beginning<00:13:23.680> the<00:13:24.079> weor
means from the very beginning the weor
means from the very beginning the weor
already<00:13:25.760> has<00:13:26.000> already<00:13:26.440> convinced<00:13:26.880> the
already has already convinced the
already has already convinced the
Chinese<00:13:27.360> government<00:13:28.000> we<00:13:28.160> will<00:13:28.399> not<00:13:28.600> be<00:13:28.880> become
Chinese government we will not be become
Chinese government we will not be become
the<00:13:29.399> stage<00:13:30.160> for<00:13:30.880> any<00:13:31.120> kind<00:13:31.320> of<00:13:31.440> a<00:13:31.600> threat<00:13:32.120> to
the stage for any kind of a threat to
the stage for any kind of a threat to
the<00:13:32.480> regime<00:13:33.160> for<00:13:33.360> example<00:13:34.000> anything<00:13:34.399> you<00:13:34.519> want
the regime for example anything you want
the regime for example anything you want
to<00:13:34.880> post<00:13:35.360> like<00:13:35.839> get<00:13:36.160> together<00:13:36.519> or<00:13:36.680> meet<00:13:36.959> up<00:13:37.360> or
to post like get together or meet up or
to post like get together or meet up or
work<00:13:38.480> it<00:13:38.680> will<00:13:39.360> automatically<00:13:40.360> will<00:13:40.600> recorded
work it will automatically will recorded
work it will automatically will recorded
and<00:13:41.560> data<00:13:42.120> mined<00:13:43.120> and<00:13:43.519> reported<00:13:44.160> to<00:13:44.959> a<00:13:45.199> pool
and data mined and reported to a pool
and data mined and reported to a pool
for<00:13:46.440> further<00:13:47.160> an<00:13:47.600> political<00:13:48.000> analysing<00:13:48.800> even
for further an political analysing even
for further an political analysing even
you<00:13:49.160> want<00:13:49.360> to<00:13:49.680> have<00:13:49.959> some<00:13:50.240> gathering<00:13:51.199> before
you want to have some gathering before
you want to have some gathering before
you<00:13:51.800> go<00:13:52.040> there<00:13:52.560> the<00:13:52.800> place<00:13:53.040> is<00:13:53.199> already
you go there the place is already
you go there the place is already
waiting<00:13:53.839> for<00:13:54.040> you<00:13:54.920> why<00:13:55.160> because<00:13:55.440> they<00:13:55.560> have
waiting for you why because they have
waiting for you why because they have
the<00:13:55.959> data<00:13:56.560> they<00:13:56.720> have<00:13:57.040> everything<00:13:57.519> in<00:13:57.680> their
the data they have everything in their
the data they have everything in their
hand<00:13:58.519> so<00:13:58.759> so<00:13:58.959> they<00:13:59.079> you<00:13:59.240> can<00:13:59.399> they<00:13:59.519> can<00:13:59.680> use<00:13:59.920> the
hand so so they you can they can use the
hand so so they you can they can use the
1984<00:14:01.839> scenario<00:14:02.839> data<00:14:03.199> mining<00:14:03.920> of<00:14:04.079> the
1984 scenario data mining of the
1984 scenario data mining of the
disident<00:14:05.160> so<00:14:05.360> the<00:14:05.480> Crackdown<00:14:06.040> is<00:14:06.240> very
disident so the Crackdown is very
disident so the Crackdown is very
serious<00:14:08.480> but<00:14:08.920> I<00:14:09.040> want<00:14:09.320> you<00:14:09.600> notice<00:14:09.920> a<00:14:10.079> very
serious but I want you notice a very
serious but I want you notice a very
funny<00:14:10.680> thing<00:14:11.320> during<00:14:11.759> the<00:14:12.000> process<00:14:12.399> of<00:14:12.600> the
funny thing during the process of the
funny thing during the process of the
cat<00:14:13.040> and<00:14:13.320> mouse<00:14:14.320> the<00:14:14.560> cat<00:14:15.079> is<00:14:15.199> the<00:14:15.360> censorship
cat and mouse the cat is the censorship
cat and mouse the cat is the censorship
but<00:14:16.079> Chinese<00:14:16.759> is<00:14:16.920> not<00:14:17.120> only<00:14:17.399> one<00:14:17.720> cat<00:14:18.360> but<00:14:18.519> I
but Chinese is not only one cat but I
but Chinese is not only one cat but I
also<00:14:18.920> have<00:14:19.160> local<00:14:19.519> cats<00:14:19.800> Central<00:14:20.240> cat<00:14:20.639> and
also have local cats Central cat and
also have local cats Central cat and
local
local
local
cats<00:14:23.519> you<00:14:23.639> know<00:14:24.360> server<00:14:24.959> is<00:14:25.120> in<00:14:25.320> the<00:14:25.480> local
cats you know server is in the local
cats you know server is in the local
cat's<00:14:26.199> hands<00:14:26.959> so<00:14:27.199> it<00:14:27.480> let<00:14:28.440> when<00:14:29.040> the<00:14:29.199> Nan
cat's hands so it let when the Nan
cat's hands so it let when the Nan
criticize<00:14:30.399> local<00:14:30.720> government<00:14:31.519> local
criticize local government local
criticize local government local
government<00:14:32.240> has<00:14:32.440> no<00:14:32.839> any<00:14:33.279> access<00:14:34.079> of<00:14:34.320> the<00:14:34.519> data
government has no any access of the data
government has no any access of the data
in<00:14:34.959> Beijing<00:14:35.959> without<00:14:36.320> bribing<00:14:36.800> the<00:14:36.959> central
in Beijing without bribing the central
in Beijing without bribing the central
cast<00:14:38.199> he<00:14:38.360> can<00:14:38.519> do<00:14:38.759> nothing<00:14:39.360> only<00:14:40.279> apologize<00:14:41.279> so
cast he can do nothing only apologize so
cast he can do nothing only apologize so
this<00:14:42.399> three<00:14:42.720> year<00:14:42.959> in<00:14:43.079> the<00:14:43.240> past<00:14:43.480> three<00:14:43.680> years
this three year in the past three years
this three year in the past three years
social<00:14:44.320> movement<00:14:45.040> about<00:14:45.800> micro<00:14:46.199> blogging
social movement about micro blogging
social movement about micro blogging
really<00:14:47.320> changed<00:14:47.880> local<00:14:48.199> government<00:14:48.920> they<00:14:49.079> can
really changed local government they can
really changed local government they can
more<00:14:49.639> become<00:14:49.959> more<00:14:50.160> and<00:14:50.320> more<00:14:50.600> transparent
more become more and more transparent
more become more and more transparent
because<00:14:52.000> they<00:14:52.240> can't<00:14:52.959> access<00:14:53.360> the<00:14:53.560> data<00:14:54.120> the
because they can't access the data the
because they can't access the data the
server<00:14:54.880> is<00:14:55.040> in
server is in
server is in
Beijing<00:14:57.639> the<00:14:57.839> story<00:14:58.160> about<00:14:58.360> TR<00:14:58.759> crash<00:14:59.279> maybe
Beijing the story about TR crash maybe
Beijing the story about TR crash maybe
the<00:14:59.759> question<00:15:00.079> is<00:15:00.279> not<00:15:00.519> about<00:15:01.240> why<00:15:01.759> 10<00:15:02.040> million
the question is not about why 10 million
the question is not about why 10 million
criticism<00:15:03.199> in<00:15:03.440> 5<00:15:03.720> days<00:15:04.279> but<00:15:04.680> why<00:15:05.360> Chinese
criticism in 5 days but why Chinese
criticism in 5 days but why Chinese
central<00:15:06.199> government<00:15:06.560> allow<00:15:07.519> the<00:15:07.759> five<00:15:08.040> days
central government allow the five days
central government allow the five days
of<00:15:08.480> freedom<00:15:08.800> of<00:15:08.920> speech<00:15:09.279> online<00:15:09.839> it<00:15:10.040> never
of freedom of speech online it never
of freedom of speech online it never
happened<00:15:11.040> before<00:15:12.040> answer<00:15:12.399> is<00:15:12.600> very<00:15:12.880> simple
happened before answer is very simple
happened before answer is very simple
because<00:15:13.880> even<00:15:14.399> the<00:15:14.639> top<00:15:14.800> leaders<00:15:15.160> was<00:15:15.399> fed<00:15:15.680> up
because even the top leaders was fed up
because even the top leaders was fed up
with<00:15:16.279> this<00:15:16.560> guy<00:15:17.160> this<00:15:17.600> independent<00:15:18.199> Kingdom
with this guy this independent Kingdom
with this guy this independent Kingdom
so<00:15:19.000> they<00:15:19.120> want<00:15:19.600> excuse<00:15:20.519> so<00:15:20.759> public<00:15:21.040> opinion<00:15:21.360> is
so they want excuse so public opinion is
so they want excuse so public opinion is
very<00:15:21.880> good<00:15:22.160> excuse<00:15:22.800> to<00:15:23.000> punish<00:15:23.440> him<00:15:24.440> but<00:15:24.600> also
very good excuse to punish him but also
very good excuse to punish him but also
the<00:15:25.000> Bosa<00:15:25.560> case<00:15:25.759> recently<00:15:26.320> very<00:15:26.480> big<00:15:26.680> news
the Bosa case recently very big news
the Bosa case recently very big news
he's<00:15:27.240> princeling<00:15:28.199> but<00:15:28.360> in<00:15:28.720> from<00:15:28.959> the<00:15:29.079> febrary
he's princeling but in from the febrary
he's princeling but in from the febrary
to<00:15:30.120> the<00:15:30.319> April<00:15:30.800> in<00:15:31.240> this<00:15:31.680> year<00:15:32.360> W<00:15:32.920> really
to the April in this year W really
to the April in this year W really
become<00:15:33.440> a<00:15:33.600> Marketplace<00:15:34.319> of<00:15:34.560> rumors<00:15:35.120> you<00:15:35.240> can
become a Marketplace of rumors you can
become a Marketplace of rumors you can
almost<00:15:35.759> joke<00:15:36.199> everything<00:15:36.639> about<00:15:37.399> this
almost joke everything about this
almost joke everything about this
princelings<00:15:38.360> everything<00:15:39.040> it's<00:15:39.240> almost<00:15:39.600> you
princelings everything it's almost you
princelings everything it's almost you
are<00:15:39.880> living<00:15:40.120> in<00:15:40.199> the<00:15:40.360> United<00:15:40.759> States<00:15:41.759> but<00:15:42.000> if
are living in the United States but if
are living in the United States but if
you<00:15:42.360> dare<00:15:42.839> to<00:15:43.440> retreat<00:15:44.079> or<00:15:44.279> mention<00:15:44.920> any<00:15:45.279> fake
you dare to retreat or mention any fake
you dare to retreat or mention any fake
coup<00:15:46.480> about<00:15:46.759> Beijing<00:15:47.240> in<00:15:47.399> Beijing<00:15:48.040> you
coup about Beijing in Beijing you
coup about Beijing in Beijing you
definitely<00:15:49.000> will<00:15:49.160> be<00:15:49.440> arrested<00:15:50.440> so<00:15:50.800> this<00:15:51.040> kind
definitely will be arrested so this kind
definitely will be arrested so this kind
of<00:15:51.440> freedom<00:15:52.440> is<00:15:52.839> targeted<00:15:54.040> and<00:15:55.040> precise
of freedom is targeted and precise
of freedom is targeted and precise
window<00:15:56.720> so<00:15:57.360> Chinese<00:15:58.000> in<00:15:58.199> China<00:15:58.759> censorship<00:15:59.319> is
window so Chinese in China censorship is
window so Chinese in China censorship is
normal<00:16:00.079> something<00:16:00.440> you<00:16:00.600> find<00:16:00.920> is<00:16:01.120> freedom<00:16:01.880> is
normal something you find is freedom is
normal something you find is freedom is
weird<00:16:02.720> something<00:16:03.000> will<00:16:03.240> happen<00:16:03.680> behind
weird something will happen behind
weird something will happen behind
because<00:16:05.279> he<00:16:05.440> was<00:16:05.720> very<00:16:06.160> popular<00:16:06.720> leftist
because he was very popular leftist
because he was very popular leftist
leader<00:16:07.839> so<00:16:08.079> central<00:16:08.440> government<00:16:08.759> want<00:16:09.000> to
leader so central government want to
leader so central government want to
purge<00:16:09.639> him<00:16:10.120> they<00:16:10.279> need<00:16:10.560> very<00:16:11.040> cute<00:16:11.240> to
purge him they need very cute to
purge him they need very cute to
convince<00:16:12.160> the<00:16:12.880> all<00:16:13.160> the<00:16:13.319> Chinese<00:16:13.800> people<00:16:14.399> why
convince the all the Chinese people why
convince the all the Chinese people why
he's<00:16:14.920> so<00:16:15.199> bad<00:16:15.880> so<00:16:16.480> the<00:16:16.880> the<00:16:17.120> wayo<00:16:17.759> 300<00:16:18.240> million
he's so bad so the the wayo 300 million
he's so bad so the the wayo 300 million
public<00:16:19.120> sphere<00:16:19.839> become<00:16:20.360> very<00:16:20.680> good
public sphere become very good
public sphere become very good
convenient<00:16:21.800> tour<00:16:22.319> for<00:16:22.600> political<00:16:23.519> fight<00:16:24.519> but
convenient tour for political fight but
convenient tour for political fight but
this<00:16:25.000> technology<00:16:25.440> is<00:16:25.639> very<00:16:25.920> new<00:16:26.399> but
this technology is very new but
this technology is very new but
technique<00:16:27.079> is<00:16:27.319> very<00:16:27.519> old<00:16:28.079> it<00:16:28.240> made<00:16:28.720> Famous<00:16:29.120> by
technique is very old it made Famous by
technique is very old it made Famous by
chairman<00:16:29.800> ma<00:16:30.120> maon<00:16:31.079> because<00:16:31.279> he<00:16:31.560> mobilized
chairman ma maon because he mobilized
chairman ma maon because he mobilized
millions<00:16:33.000> of<00:16:33.160> Chinese<00:16:33.519> people<00:16:33.759> in<00:16:33.839> the
millions of Chinese people in the
millions of Chinese people in the
cultural<00:16:34.440> revolution<00:16:35.120> to<00:16:36.120> destroy<00:16:36.720> every
cultural revolution to destroy every
cultural revolution to destroy every
local<00:16:37.399> government<00:16:38.120> it's<00:16:38.319> very<00:16:38.519> simple
local government it's very simple
local government it's very simple
because<00:16:39.639> Chinese<00:16:40.120> central<00:16:40.440> government<00:16:40.720> don't
because Chinese central government don't
because Chinese central government don't
need<00:16:41.240> even<00:16:41.440> lead<00:16:41.920> the<00:16:42.079> public<00:16:42.360> opinion<00:16:42.880> they
need even lead the public opinion they
need even lead the public opinion they
just<00:16:43.680> give<00:16:44.000> them<00:16:44.560> a<00:16:44.720> Target<00:16:45.240> window<00:16:45.720> no<00:16:46.120> censor
just give them a Target window no censor
just give them a Target window no censor
people<00:16:47.680> not<00:16:48.079> censoring<00:16:49.000> in<00:16:49.199> China<00:16:49.800> become<00:16:50.720> a
people not censoring in China become a
people not censoring in China become a
political
political
political
toour<00:16:53.440> so<00:16:53.800> that's<00:16:54.000> the<00:16:54.199> update<00:16:54.759> about<00:16:55.160> this
toour so that's the update about this
toour so that's the update about this
game<00:16:56.199> cat<00:16:56.399> and<00:16:56.519> the<00:16:56.639> mouse<00:16:57.399> social<00:16:57.680> media
game cat and the mouse social media
game cat and the mouse social media
change<00:16:58.480> Chinese<00:16:58.800> mindset<00:16:59.560> more<00:16:59.720> and<00:16:59.880> more
change Chinese mindset more and more
change Chinese mindset more and more
chinesee<00:17:00.720> intend<00:17:01.199> to<00:17:01.480> embrace<00:17:02.120> freedom
chinesee intend to embrace freedom
chinesee intend to embrace freedom
speech<00:17:02.920> and<00:17:03.120> human<00:17:03.480> rights<00:17:03.959> as<00:17:04.120> their
speech and human rights as their
speech and human rights as their
Birthright<00:17:05.240> not<00:17:05.559> some<00:17:06.199> important<00:17:07.039> American
Birthright not some important American
Birthright not some important American
privilege<00:17:08.919> but<00:17:09.160> also<00:17:09.799> it<00:17:10.079> gave<00:17:10.360> Chinese<00:17:11.000> a
privilege but also it gave Chinese a
privilege but also it gave Chinese a
national<00:17:11.839> public<00:17:12.079> Sphere<00:17:12.480> for<00:17:12.720> people<00:17:13.360> to
national public Sphere for people to
national public Sphere for people to
it's<00:17:14.280> like<00:17:14.480> a<00:17:14.640> training<00:17:15.319> of<00:17:15.559> their
it's like a training of their
it's like a training of their
citizenship<00:17:17.120> preparing<00:17:17.640> for<00:17:17.880> the<00:17:18.439> future
citizenship preparing for the future
citizenship preparing for the future
democracy<00:17:19.480> but<00:17:19.640> it<00:17:19.760> didn't<00:17:20.039> change<00:17:20.439> Chinese
democracy but it didn't change Chinese
democracy but it didn't change Chinese
political<00:17:21.319> system<00:17:22.079> and<00:17:22.280> also<00:17:23.039> Chinese
political system and also Chinese
political system and also Chinese
central<00:17:23.839> government<00:17:24.199> utilized<00:17:24.839> this
central government utilized this
central government utilized this
centralized<00:17:26.240> server<00:17:26.799> structure<00:17:27.559> to
centralized server structure to
centralized server structure to
strengthen<00:17:28.240> his<00:17:28.640> power<00:17:28.960> to<00:17:29.120> control<00:17:29.480> the
strengthen his power to control the
strengthen his power to control the
local<00:17:29.880> government<00:17:30.600> and<00:17:30.840> the<00:17:31.039> different
local government and the different
local government and the different
factions<00:17:33.960> so<00:17:34.960> what's<00:17:35.160> the<00:17:35.320> future<00:17:36.080> but<00:17:36.280> after
factions so what's the future but after
factions so what's the future but after
all<00:17:37.120> we<00:17:37.280> are<00:17:37.720> the<00:17:37.880> mouse<00:17:38.799> whatever<00:17:39.160> the<00:17:39.280> future
all we are the mouse whatever the future
all we are the mouse whatever the future
is<00:17:39.960> we<00:17:40.039> should<00:17:40.400> fight<00:17:40.960> against<00:17:41.400> the
is we should fight against the
is we should fight against the
mouse<00:17:43.320> there<00:17:43.520> is<00:17:44.000> not<00:17:44.160> only<00:17:44.559> in<00:17:44.720> China<00:17:45.039> but
mouse there is not only in China but
mouse there is not only in China but
also<00:17:45.400> in<00:17:45.520> the<00:17:45.640> United<00:17:46.000> States<00:17:46.400> there<00:17:46.520> are<00:17:46.679> know
also in the United States there are know
also in the United States there are know
some<00:17:47.600> very<00:17:48.280> small<00:17:49.280> cute<00:17:49.760> but<00:17:50.000> bad
some very small cute but bad
some very small cute but bad
cats<00:17:52.840> so
cats so
cats so
P<00:17:55.600> ecta<00:17:56.600> TPP<00:17:57.320> and<00:17:58.000> itu
P ecta TPP and itu
P ecta TPP and itu
you<00:18:00.080> and<00:18:00.280> also<00:18:00.919> like<00:18:01.240> Facebook<00:18:01.960> and<00:18:02.360> the
you and also like Facebook and the
you and also like Facebook and the
Google<00:18:02.799> they<00:18:02.960> claim<00:18:03.360> they<00:18:03.480> are<00:18:03.640> friends<00:18:04.080> of
Google they claim they are friends of
Google they claim they are friends of
the<00:18:04.360> mouse<00:18:05.120> but<00:18:05.559> sometimes<00:18:05.880> we<00:18:06.000> see<00:18:06.240> them
the mouse but sometimes we see them
the mouse but sometimes we see them
dating<00:18:07.240> with<00:18:07.480> the
dating with the
dating with the
cats<00:18:09.200> so<00:18:10.080> my<00:18:10.400> conclusion<00:18:11.080> is<00:18:11.280> very<00:18:11.520> simple<00:18:12.400> we
cats so my conclusion is very simple we
cats so my conclusion is very simple we
Chinese<00:18:13.159> fight<00:18:13.640> our<00:18:13.919> for<00:18:14.120> our<00:18:14.559> freedom<00:18:15.559> you
Chinese fight our for our freedom you
Chinese fight our for our freedom you
just<00:18:16.480> watch<00:18:17.240> your<00:18:17.559> bad<00:18:17.960> cats<00:18:18.760> don't<00:18:19.000> let<00:18:19.240> them
just watch your bad cats don't let them
just watch your bad cats don't let them
to<00:18:19.640> hook<00:18:19.919> with<00:18:20.039> the<00:18:20.240> Chinese<00:18:20.919> cats<00:18:21.919> only<00:18:22.360> in
to hook with the Chinese cats only in
to hook with the Chinese cats only in
this<00:18:23.520> in<00:18:23.679> the<00:18:23.840> future<00:18:24.360> we<00:18:24.520> will<00:18:24.799> achieve
this in the future we will achieve
this in the future we will achieve
achieve<00:18:25.799> the<00:18:26.000> dreams<00:18:26.760> of<00:18:26.960> the<00:18:27.080> mouse<00:18:27.840> that<00:18:28.039> we
achieve the dreams of the mouse that we
achieve the dreams of the mouse that we
can<00:18:28.400> can<00:18:28.520> treat<00:18:28.960> anytime<00:18:29.799> anywhere<00:18:30.760> without
fear<00:18:39.440> thank
you
Michael Anti, TED, China, Censorship, Chinese, censorship, internet, Google, Facebook, TED-Ed, TED, Ed, TEDEducation
