Is fire a solid, a liquid, or a gas? - Elizabeth Cox
Sitting around a campfire,
you can feel its heat,
smell the woody smoke,
and hear it crackle.
If you get too close,
it burns your eyes
and stings your nostrils.
You could stare at the bright
flames forever
as they twist and flicker
in endless incarnations.
But what exactly are you looking at?
The flames are obviously not solid,
nor are they liquid.
Mingling with the air, they’re
more like a gas,
but more visible--and more fleeting.
And on a scientific level,
fire differs from gas
because gases can exist in
the same state indefinitely
while fires always burn out eventually.
One misconception is that
fire is a plasma,
the fourth state of matter in which atoms
are stripped of their electrons.
Like fire and unlike the
other kinds of matter,
plasmas don’t exist in a stable
state on earth.
They only form when gas is exposed
to an electric field or superheated
to temperatures of thousands
or tens of thousands of degrees.
By contrast, fuels like wood
and paper burn
at a few hundred degrees —far below the
threshold of what's usually
considered a plasma.
So if fire isn’t a solid, liquid, gas,
or a plasma, what does that leave?
It turns out fire isn’t actually
matter at all.
Instead, it’s our sensory experience of a
chemical reaction called combustion.
In a way, fire is like the leaves
changing color in fall,
the smell of fruit as it ripens,
or a firefly’s blinking light.
All of these are sensory clues that a
chemical reaction is taking place.
What differs about fire is that
it engages a lot of
our senses at the same time,
creating the kind of vivid
experience we expect to come
from a physical thing.
Combustion creates that sensory experience
using fuel, heat, and oxygen.
In a campfire, when the logs are
heated to their ignition temperature,
the walls of their cells decompose,
releasing sugars and other
molecules into the air.
These molecules then react
with airborne oxygen
to create carbon dioxide and water.
At the same time, any trapped
water in the logs
vaporizes, expands, ruptures
the wood around it,
and escapes with a satisfying crackle.
As the fire heats up, the carbon
dioxide and water vapor
created by combustion expand.
Now that they’re less dense,
they rise in a thinning column.
Gravity causes this expansion and rising,
which gives
flames their characteristic taper.
Without gravity, molecules don’t separate
by density and the flames
have a totally different shape.
We can see all of this because combustion
also generates light.
Molecules emit light when heated,
and the color of the light depends
on the temperature of the molecules.
The hottest flames are white or blue.
The type of molecules in a fire can
also influence flame color.
For instance, any unreacted
carbon atoms from the logs
form little clumps of soot that rise
into the flames and emit the yellow-orange
light we associate with a campfire.
Substances like copper, calcium chloride,
and potassium chloride can add their
own characteristic hues to the mix.
Besides colorful flames,
fire also continues to generate heat
as it burns.
This heat sustains the flames by keeping
the fuel at or above ignition temperature.
Eventually, though, even the hottest fires
run out of fuel or oxygen.
Then, those twisting flames
give a final hiss
and disappear with a wisp of smoke
as if they were never there at all.
